放射治疗质量保证对鼻咽癌的影响:一种新型网络化质量保证应用的使用
本研究利用新型网络应用快速审阅354例病理确诊鼻咽癌患者的调强放疗靶区,其中332例原发肿瘤中危临床靶区(CTVp)轮廓按2018国际指南评估符合性。中位随访5.6年,5年局部无失败时间(TTLF)和总生存率分别为93.1%和85.9%;海绵窦覆盖不足与TTLF相关(符合者93.6% vs 不符合者89.1%,P=.013),多因素分析证实海绵窦不符合为TTLF的预后因素。
要点
- 同行审阅质量保证分析中,审阅与非审阅病例、靶区轮廓修改与未修改病例的局部控制、远处控制及总生存率相似。
- 332例CTVp按2018国际指南评估,最常不符合的解剖部位为蝶窦(69例,20.8%)、海绵窦(38例,19.3%)、左岩尖(37例,11.1%)、右岩尖(32例,9.6%)和斜坡(14例,4.2%)。
- 23例局部失败(6.9%)中,不符合病例数为蝶窦8例、海绵窦7例、左岩尖4例、右岩尖3例、斜坡2例;海绵窦符合者TTLF高于不符合者(93.6% vs 89.1%,P=.013)。
核心结论
- 该应用可对大型鼻咽癌队列的CTVp进行快速定量审阅;尽管对国际指南的符合性较高,但海绵窦覆盖不足与TTLF相关。
研究设计与样本
- 数据集包括2005年至2017年间接受调强放疗的354例病理确诊鼻咽癌患者的CT模拟扫描、放疗结构和临床数据。
- 靶区在放疗质量保证轮次中同行审阅,如建议则在治疗前修改靶区轮廓;将332例原发肿瘤中危临床靶区(CTVp)轮廓导入应用。
- 根据2018年鼻咽癌CTV勾画国际指南确定中危CTVp内解剖部位的纳入,并使用Cox回归与局部失败时间(TTLF)关联。
主要发现
- 同行审阅质量保证分析中,审阅与非审阅病例之间、以及靶区轮廓修改与未修改病例之间的局部控制、远处控制和总生存率相似。
- 中位随访5.6年,5年TTLF和总生存率分别为93.1%和85.9%。
- 最常不符合指南的解剖部位为蝶窦(n=69,20.8%),其次为海绵窦(n=38,19.3%)、左岩尖(n=37,11.1%)、右岩尖(n=32,9.6%)和斜坡(n=14,4.2%)。
- 23例局部失败(6.9%)中,不符合病例数为蝶窦8例、海绵窦7例、左岩尖4例、右岩尖3例、斜坡2例。
- 海绵窦符合者TTLF高于不符合者(93.6% vs 89.1%,P=.013);多因素分析证实海绵窦不符合为TTLF的预后因素。
关键数值与推荐
- 中危CTVp内解剖部位的纳入依据2018年鼻咽癌CTV勾画国际指南确定。
- 海绵窦符合者5年TTLF为93.6%,不符合者为89.1%(P=.013)。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
PURPOSE: We used a new web application for rapid review of radiation therapy (RT) target volumes to evaluate the relationship between target delineation compliance with the international guidelines and outcomes of definitive RT for nasopharyngeal carcinoma (NPC). METHODS AND MATERIALS: The data set consisted of computed tomography simulation scans, RT structures, and clinical data of 354 patients with pathology-confirmed NPC treated with intensity modulated RT between 2005 and 2017. Target volumes were peer-reviewed in RT quality assurance rounds, and target contours were revised, if recommended, before treatment. We imported the contours of intermediate-risk clinical target volumes of the primary tumor (CTVp) of 332 patients into the application. Inclusion of anatomic sites within intermediate-risk CTVp was determined in accordance with 2018 international guidelines for CTV delineation for NPC and correlated with time to local failure (TTLF) using Cox regression. RESULTS: In the peer-review quality assurance analysis, local and distant control and overall survival rates were similar between peer-reviewed and nonreviewed cases and between cases with and without target contour changes. In the CTV compliance analysis, with a median follow-up of 5.6 years, 5-year TTLF and overall survival rates were 93.1% and 85.9%, respectively. The most frequently non-guideline-compliant anatomic sites were sphenoid sinus (n = 69, 20.8%), followed by cavernous sinus (n = 38, 19.3%), left and right petrous apices (n = 37 and 32, 11.1% and 9.6%), and clivus (n = 14, 4.2%). Among 23 patients with a local failure (6.9%), the number of noncompliant cases was 8 for sphenoid sinus, 7 cavernous sinus, 4 left and 3 right petrous apices, and 2 clivus. Cavernous sinus-conforming cases showed higher TTLF in comparison with nonconforming cases (93.6% vs 89.1%, P = .013). Multivariable analysis confirmed that cavernous sinus noncompliance was prognostic for TTLF. CONCLUSIONS: Our application allowed rapid quantitative review of CTVp in a large NPC cohort. Although compliance with the international guidelines was high, undercoverage of the cavernous sinus was correlated with TTLF.
引用
- Kim JW, Marsilla J, Kazmierski M, et al. Effect of Radiation Therapy Quality Assurance on Nasopharyngeal Carcinoma: Usage of a Novel, Web-Based Quality Assurance Application. Pract Radiat Oncol. 2023. PMID: 36948414. doi:10.1016/j.prro.2023.03.003
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。