以教育为突破口推广大分割放疗:一项全国性培训项目的结果
在哥伦比亚开展试点电子学习大分割课程,覆盖乳腺、前列腺、直肠癌及高级别胶质瘤,13次每周90分钟课程。147名临床人员入组,配对医生大分割选择从6.2/12升至8.2/12(P<.001),配对临床人员自信心在多个部位提升(P≤.03)。
要点
- 教育是医生选择大分割放疗的最大感知障碍,前列腺超大分割中占77.6%、乳腺超大分割中占74.6%。
- 课程后配对医生(n=38)大分割选择均值从6.2/12升至8.2/12,P<.001。
- 配对临床人员(n=87)自信心在前列腺超大分割(+0.45)、直肠超大分割(+0.43)、乳腺大分割(+0.38)、前列腺大分割(+0.23)提升,P≤.03。
核心结论
- 在采用捆绑支付体系的中低收入国家,缺乏教育与培训被认为是实施大分割和超大分割的感知障碍。
- 针对性电子学习大分割课程提高了参与者的自信心和大分割方案的选择。
研究设计与样本
- 在哥伦比亚开发试点电子学习大分割课程,聚焦乳腺癌、前列腺癌、直肠癌和高级别胶质瘤。
- 由国际教育者授课,共13次每周90分钟课程。
- 参与者完成课程前后问卷,评估大分割态度、1至5级Likert自信心及12个临床场景的实践选择。
- 医生对12个临床场景的选择按分类评分:「1」代表大分割或超大分割,「0」代表常规分割。
- 使用配对t检验比较课程前后自信心差异,使用McNemar检验检测大分割选择差异。
主要发现
- 来自哥伦比亚19个城市的147名临床人员入组:61名放射肿瘤科医生、6名放射肿瘤科住院医师、59名医学物理师、18名物理住院医师和3名其他人员。
- 医生中,教育是选择大分割的最大障碍,在前列腺超大分割中占77.6%、乳腺超大分割中占74.6%,在前列腺中度大分割中占61.2%、乳腺中度大分割中占52.2%。
- 其他感知障碍包括不熟悉临床方案(7%-22%)、临床经验(5%-15%)、个人偏好(3%-16%)和缺乏技术(3%-20%),不同临床环境间存在差异。
- 课程后,配对医生(n=38)在所有疾病部位的大分割选择均增加,平均聚合评分从6.2/12升至8.2/12,P<.001。
- 配对临床人员(n=87)的自信心在前列腺超大分割(+0.45)、直肠超大分割(+0.43)、乳腺大分割(+0.38)和前列腺大分割(+0.23)方面均提高,P≤.03。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: Access to radiation therapy in low- and middle-income countries (LMICs) could be improved with modern hypofractionated radiation therapy schedules, although their adoption remains limited. We aimed to evaluate perceptions regarding hypofractionation and the effect of a dedicated curriculum in an LMIC. METHODS AND MATERIALS: We developed a pilot e-learning hypofractionation curriculum focused on breast, prostate, rectal cancer, and high-grade glioma in Colombia. International educators taught 13 weekly, 90-minute sessions. Participants completed pre- and postcurriculum questionnaires regarding hypofractionation attitudes, 1 to 5 Likert-scale self-confidence, and practices for 12 clinical scenarios. Physicians' responses were categorically scored "1" (for hypofractionation or ultrahypofractionation) or "0" (for conventional fractionation). We used the paired t test to measure pre- versus postcurriculum differences in self-confidence and the McNemar test to detect differences in hypofractionation selection. RESULTS: Across 19 cities in Colombia, 147 clinicians enrolled: 61 radiation oncologists, 6 radiation oncology residents, 59 medical physicists, 18 physics residents, and 3 other staff. Among physicians, education was the greatest barrier to select hypofractionation, common in ultrahypofractionation for prostate (77.6%) and breast cancer (74.6%) and less common for moderate hypofractionation of prostate (61.2%) and breast cancer (52.2%). Additional perceived barriers included unfamiliarity with clinic protocols (7%-22%), clinical experience (5%-15%), personal preference (3%-16%), and lack of technology (3%-20%), with variation across different clinical settings. After the curriculum, paired (n = 38) physicians' selection of hypofractionation increased across all disease sites (mean aggregate score 6.2/12 vs 8.2/12, P <.001). Self-confidence among paired clinicians (n = 87) increased for prostate ultrahypofractionation (+0.45), rectal ultrahypofractionation (+0.43), breast hypofractionation (+0.38), and prostate hypofractionation (+0.23) (P ≤ .03). CONCLUSIONS: In an LMIC with a bundled payment system, lack of education and training was a perceived barrier for implementation of hypofractionation and ultrahypofractionation. A targeted e-learning hypofractionation curriculum increased participant confidence and selection of hypofractionated schedules.
引用
- Caicedo-Martínez M, Li B, González-Motta A, et al. Targeting Education as a Barrier to Implement Hypofractionation: Results of a Country-Wide Training Program. Adv Radiat Oncol. 2022. PMID: 36760343. doi:10.1016/j.adro.2022.101165
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。