估算基于直线加速器的外照射放疗的二氧化碳排放与直接电力消耗
该研究估算了4种常见癌症 curative-intent 外照射放疗中直线加速器能耗对应的二氧化碳排放。每疗程平均碳排放最低为前列腺SBRT(2.18 kg CO2,四分位距1.92-2.30),最高为前列腺癌常规放疗(17.34 kg CO2,四分位距10.26-23.79)。直线加速器待机模式每日耗能最高,TrueBeam和Clinac IX分别为112 kWh和64.8 kWh。
要点
- 前列腺SBRT每疗程平均碳排放最低(2.18 kg CO2),常规前列腺癌放疗最高(17.34 kg CO2)。
- 直线加速器TrueBeam和Clinac IX待机模式每日分别耗电112 kWh和64.8 kWh。
- 作者认为需开展全面研究以尽量减少医疗和癌症护理的环境影响。
核心结论
- 研究估算了4种常见癌症外照射放疗中直线加速器直接能耗产生的二氧化碳排放,并指出直线加速器待机模式每日耗能最高,作者认为需开展全面研究以减少医疗和癌症护理的环境影响。
研究设计与样本
- 研究纳入4种最常见癌症类型接受根治性外照射放疗的患者,每种治疗模式各10例,从治疗计划系统提取每次分次的束流时间并按部位和治疗模式取平均,乘以功率得到千瓦时,再用美国环境保护署温室气体等效计算器换算为美国平均电网的二氧化碳当量排放,直线加速器空闲时间由Varian Medical Systems估算。
主要发现
- 每疗程平均碳排放最低和最高的模式分别为前列腺SBRT(2.18 kg CO2,四分位距1.92-2.30)和前列腺癌常规治疗(17.34 kg CO2,四分位距10.26-23.79)。
- 上述碳排放分别相当于标准车辆平均行驶5.4英里和41.2英里的二氧化碳当量排放。
- 直线加速器TrueBeam和Clinac IX的待机模式每日分别耗电112 kWh和64.8 kWh。
关键数值与推荐
- 纳入的治疗模式包括:前列腺癌常规分割放疗(28次)、前列腺SBRT(5次)、早期乳腺癌15次和5次方案、早期肺癌3次和5次SBRT方案、局部晚期肺癌常规外照射放疗(30次)、直肠癌短程(5次)和长程(25-28次)方案。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
PURPOSE: Climate change is one of the direst health threats that humanity faces. We aim to estimate the carbon dioxide (CO2) emissions associated with the energy usage from linear accelerator (LINAC)-based external beam radiation therapy (EBRT) for the most common cancer diagnoses. METHODS AND MATERIALS: We identified patients with the 4 most common cancer types treated with curative-intent EBRT. Beam-on time for each fraction was extracted from the treatment planning system and averaged over each site and treatment modality. The power was multiplied by the beam-on time in hours to yield kilowatt hours (kWh). Using the US Environmental Protection Agency Greenhouse Gas Equivalencies calculator, we converted the kWh into estimates of CO2-equivalent emissions for the average US power grid. Idle time of the LINAC was estimated via Varian Medical Systems. RESULTS: A total of 10 patients were included for each of the following modalities: conventionally fractionated for prostate cancer (28 fractions [fx]), prostate stereotactic body radiation therapy (SBRT) (5 fx), 15- and 5-fx regimens for early-stage breast cancer, 3- and 5-fx SBRT regimens for early-stage lung cancer, conventional EBRT (30 fx) for locally advanced lung cancer, and short- (5 fx) and long-course (25-28 fx) for rectal cancer. The modality with the lowest and highest carbon emissions per course, on average, was prostate SBRT (2.18 kg CO2; interquartile range, 1.92-2.30) and conventional treatment for prostate cancer (17.34 kg CO2; interquartile range, 10.26-23.79), respectively. This corresponds to CO2-equivalent emissions of driving an average of 5.4 miles and 41.2 miles in a standard vehicle, respectively. "Standby" mode for a LINAC TrueBeam and Clinac IX uses 112 kWh and 64.8 kWh per day, respectively. CONCLUSIONS: We have estimated CO2 emissions arising from direct energy usage of a LINAC for 4 common cancers treated with EBRT. "Standby" mode of a LINAC uses the most energy per day. Comprehensive studies are warranted to minimize the environmental effects of health and cancer care.
引用
- Shenker RF, Johnson TL, Ribeiro M, et al. Estimating Carbon Dioxide Emissions and Direct Power Consumption of Linear Accelerator-Based External Beam Radiation Therapy. Adv Radiat Oncol. 2022. PMID: 36798606. doi:10.1016/j.adro.2022.101170
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。