自动分割靶区随机离群点对胶质母细胞瘤放疗计划的影响
本研究通过合成离群点的控制实验(61种模拟场景)及基于80例胶质母细胞瘤(GBM)病例训练的U-Net分割模型预测,分析自动分割靶区离群点的发生及其剂量效应。含离群点的计划增加健康脑组织剂量,剂量效应程度取决于相对大小、位置及与主靶区和危及器官的距离;120个预测的GTV和水肿结构中检出1887个离群点,构建PTV后残留137个,平均距离靶区38.5±5.0 mm,平均大小1010.8±95.6 mm3。作者结论为当前DL预测靶结构存在假阳性离群点的严重风险,这些误差对剂量有明显不利影响,可能影响治疗结果。
要点
- 含离群点的计划增加健康脑组织剂量,效应取决于相对大小、位置及与主靶区和危及器官的距离。
- 120个预测GTV和水肿结构中检出1887个离群点,构建PTV后残留137个。
- 残留离群点平均距离靶区38.5±5.0 mm,平均大小1010.8±95.6 mm3;多数投票可减少离群点。
核心结论
- 当前深度学习预测靶结构存在假阳性离群点的严重风险,这些误差对剂量有明显不利影响,可能影响治疗结果。
研究设计与样本
- 对一名胶质母细胞瘤患者CT进行合成离群点的控制实验,共61种模拟场景,分析不同位置、形状、绝对大小及相对主靶区大小离群点的剂量影响。
- 基于80套含GTV和水肿结构注释的胶质母细胞瘤病例训练集,在U-Net网络上训练多个分割模型;在20例测试病例上使用5个不同训练模型及多数投票法预测GTV和水肿,确定预测离群点的数量、大小及与真实靶区的距离。
主要发现
- 含离群点的计划导致健康脑组织剂量增加。
- 剂量效应程度取决于离群点的相对大小、位置及与主靶区和相关危及器官的距离。
- 通常离群点绝对体积越大、与靶区距离越远,潜在剂量效应越高。
- 120个预测的GTV和水肿结构中检出1887个离群点;构建PTV后残留137个离群点,平均距离靶区38.5±5.0 mm,平均大小1010.8±95.6 mm3。
- 深度学习结果的多数投票能够减少离群点。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
AIMS: To save time and have more consistent contours, fully automatic segmentation of targets and organs at risk (OAR) is a valuable asset in radiotherapy. Though current deep learning (DL) based models are on par with manual contouring, they are not perfect and typical errors, as false positives, occur frequently and unpredictably. While it is possible to solve this for OARs, it is far from straightforward for target structures. In order to tackle this problem, in this study, we analyzed the occurrence and the possible dose effects of automated delineation outliers. METHODS: First, a set of controlled experiments on synthetically generated outliers on the CT of a glioblastoma (GBM) patient was performed. We analyzed the dosimetric impact on outliers with different location, shape, absolute size and relative size to the main target, resulting in 61 simulated scenarios. Second, multiple segmentation models where trained on a U-Net network based on 80 training sets consisting of GBM cases with annotated gross tumor volume (GTV) and edema structures. On 20 test cases, 5 different trained models and a majority voting method were used to predict the GTV and edema. The amount of outliers on the predictions were determined, as well as their size and distance from the actual target. RESULTS: We found that plans containing outliers result in an increased dose to healthy brain tissue. The extent of the dose effect is dependent on the relative size, location and the distance to the main targets and involved OARs. Generally, the larger the absolute outlier volume and the distance to the target the higher the potential dose effect. For 120 predicted GTV and edema structures, we found 1887 outliers. After construction of the planning treatment volume (PTV), 137 outliers remained with a mean distance to the target of 38.5 ± 5.0 mm and a mean size of 1010.8 ± 95.6 mm3. We also found that majority voting of DL results is capable to reduce outliers. CONCLUSIONS: This study shows that there is a severe risk of false positive outliers in current DL predictions of target structures. Additionally, these errors will have an evident detrimental impact on the dose and therefore could affect treatment outcome.
引用
- Poel R, Rüfenacht E, Ermis E, et al. Impact of random outliers in auto-segmented targets on radiotherapy treatment plans for glioblastoma. Radiat Oncol. 2022. PMID: 36273161. doi:10.1186/s13014-022-02137-9
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。