MRI引导放疗中自动传播的前列腺轮廓与手动勾画轮廓的剂量学比较:迈向无勾画工作流程的一步?
本研究在Elekta Unity MR-Linac上比较了基于形变图像配准(DIR)和刚性图像配准(RIR)自动生成的前列腺靶区轮廓与放疗医师手动勾画轮廓的剂量学表现,共分析10例患者40次分次的计划。结果显示DIR计划中81%满足PTV 6000的强制剂量目标,而RIR计划仅45%满足;所有计划中PTV 4860均满足最优目标。作者结论认为DIR传播轮廓优于RIR,但约五分之一的DIR计划对金标准PTV的剂量覆盖临床不可接受,本机构采用DIR传播结合必要手动编辑的方式。
要点
- DIR计划中81%满足PTV 6000的D98%>5580 cGy目标,RIR计划仅45%满足。
- 所有计划中PTV 4860均满足D98%>4617 cGy的最优目标。
- 约五分之一的DIR计划对金标准PTV的剂量覆盖临床不可接受。
核心结论
- 基于DIR传播的前列腺轮廓生成的计划优于基于RIR传播的计划。
- 约五分之一的DIR计划对金标准PTV的剂量覆盖临床不可接受。
- 本机构对在线治疗采用DIR传播轮廓结合必要手动编辑的方式。
研究设计与样本
- 研究在Elekta Unity MR-Linac上比较自动生成的前列腺靶区轮廓与放疗医师手动勾画的轮廓。
- 计划由DIR和RIR传播的前列腺轮廓生成,共纳入10例患者的40次分次。
- 采用两剂量水平SIB IMRT计划治疗局限期前列腺癌,前列腺处方6000 cGy,精囊腺处方4860 cGy。
- 以手动勾画靶区生成的PTV 6000和PTV 4860评估各计划的剂量覆盖,满足剂量目标即认为成功覆盖金标准体积。
主要发现
- PTV 6000的强制剂量目标(D98%>5580 cGy)在DIR计划中81%满足,在RIR计划中45%满足。
- 精囊腺仅由DIR映射,所有计划的PTV 4860剂量目标均满足最优目标(D98%>4617 cGy)。
- RIR生成的计划导致临床医师勾画的前列腺覆盖不足,主要位于尖部或膀胱-前列腺交界处。
关键数值与推荐
- PTV 6000强制剂量目标为D98%>5580 cGy,DIR计划81%满足,RIR计划45%满足。
- PTV 4860最优剂量目标为D98%>4617 cGy,所有计划均满足。
临床怎么用
- 本研究中心对在线治疗采用DIR传播轮廓结合必要手动编辑的方式。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The prostate demonstrates inter- and intra- fractional changes and thus adaptive radiotherapy would be required to ensure optimal coverage. Daily adaptive radiotherapy for MRI-guided radiotherapy can be both time and resource intensive when structure delineation is completed manually. Contours can be auto-generated on the MR-Linac via a deformable image registration (DIR) based mapping process from the reference image. This study evaluates the performance of automatically generated target structure contours against manually delineated contours by radiation oncologists for prostate radiotherapy on the Elekta Unity MR-Linac. METHODS: Plans were generated from prostate contours propagated by DIR and rigid image registration (RIR) for forty fractions from ten patients. A two-dose level SIB (simultaneous integrated boost) IMRT plan is used to treat localised prostate cancer; 6000 cGy to the prostate and 4860 cGy to the seminal vesicles. The dose coverage of the PTV 6000 and PTV 4860 created from the manually drawn target structures was evaluated with each plan. If the dose objectives were met, the plan was considered successful in covering the gold standard (clinician-delineated) volume. RESULTS: The mandatory PTV 6000 dose objective (D98% > 5580 cGy) was met in 81 % of DIR plans and 45 % of RIR plans. The SV were mapped by DIR only and for all the plans, the PTV 4860 dose objective met the optimal target (D98% > 4617 cGy). The plans created by RIR led to under-coverage of the clinician-delineated prostate, predominantly at the apex or the bladder-prostate interface. CONCLUSION: Plans created from DIR propagation of prostate contours outperform those created from RIR propagation. In approximately 1 in 5 DIR plans, dosimetric coverage of the gold standard PTV was not clinically acceptable. Thus, at our institution, we use a combination of DIR propagation of contours alongside manual editing of contours where deemed necessary for online treatments.
引用
- Sritharan K, Dunlop A, Mohajer J, et al. Dosimetric comparison of automatically propagated prostate contours with manually drawn contours in MRI-guided radiotherapy: A step towards a contouring free workflow? Clin Transl Radiat Oncol. 2022. PMID: 36052018. doi:10.1016/j.ctro.2022.08.004
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。