基于知识的多机构全乳腺切线野放疗计划预测
十家机构采用统一方法建立基于知识(KB)的切线野全乳腺放疗计划模型,并在20例新患者上测试心脏、双肺及对侧乳腺的剂量体积直方图预测。机构间预测变异性总体有限,同侧肺平均剂量标准差为0.55 Gy,其余危及器官小于0.2 Gy;仅一家机构模型可迁移性较差。
要点
- 十家机构按统一方法建立KB模型,对20例新患者预测心脏、双肺及对侧乳腺剂量。
- 同侧肺剂量预测的机构间变异性在20%–80%剂量范围内小于2%,平均剂量标准差为0.55 Gy。
- 七家机构模型的几何主成分均在适用范围内,仅一家机构模型在7/18例中失败。
核心结论
- 计划预测模型的机构间变异性有限,机构间可交换性高,但十家机构中有一家例外。
- 作者认为该结果鼓励未来开展纳入机构间变异性的计划预测基准研究。
研究设计与样本
- 十家机构按先前共享的方法学使用RapidPlan(Varian Inc.)建立基于知识(KB)的模型。
- 模型在同机构20例新患者上测试,导出心脏、同侧肺、对侧肺和对侧乳腺的剂量体积直方图预测。
主要发现
- 在40 Gy分15次方案下,同侧肺剂量预测的机构间变异性在20%–80%剂量范围内小于2%,平均剂量为0.55 Gy(1个标准差)。
- 其他危及器官的机构间变异性小于0.2 Gy。
- 机构6的平均剂量预测值最低,且计划靶区与同侧肺无重叠;排除该机构后,预测的同侧肺平均剂量与计划靶区中位D99%相关(R²=0.78)。
- 7个模型的几何主成分(PC1)始终在适用范围内(第90百分位数);2个模型在1/18例中超出范围;机构6的模型在7/18例中失败。
- 剂量计算机构间变异性的影响经测试几乎可忽略。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
PURPOSE: To quantify inter-institute variability of Knowledge-Based (KB) models for right breast cancer patients treated with tangential fields whole breast irradiation (WBI). MATERIALS AND METHODS: Ten institutions set KB models by using RapidPlan (Varian Inc.), following previously shared methodologies. Models were tested on 20 new patients from the same institutes, exporting DVH predictions of heart, ipsilateral lung, contralateral lung, and contralateral breast. Inter-institute variability was quantified by the inter-institute SDint of predicted DVHs/Dmean. Association between lung sparing vs PTV coverage strategy was also investigated. The transferability of models was evaluated by the overlap of each model's geometric Principal Component (PC1) when applied to the test patients of the other 9 institutes. RESULTS: The overall inter-institute variability of DVH/Dmean ipsilateral lung dose prediction, was less than 2% (20%-80% dose range) and 0.55 Gy respectively (1SD) for a 40 Gy in 15 fraction schedule; it was < 0.2 Gy for other OARs. Institute 6 showed the lowest mean dose prediction value and no overlap between PTV and ipsilateral lung. Once excluded, the predicted ipsilateral lung Dmean was correlated with median PTV D99% (R2 = 0.78). PC1 values were always within the range of applicability (90th percentile) for 7 models: for 2 models they were outside in 1/18 cases. For the model of institute 6, it failed in 7/18 cases. The impact of inter-institute variability of dose calculation was tested and found to be almost negligible. CONCLUSIONS: Results show limited inter-institute variability of plan prediction models translating in high inter-institute interchangeability, except for one of ten institutes. These results encourage future investigations in generating benchmarks for plan prediction incorporating inter-institute variability.
引用
- Tudda A, Castriconi R, Benecchi G, et al. Knowledge-based multi-institution plan prediction of whole breast irradiation with tangential fields. Radiother Oncol. 2022. PMID: 35868603. doi:10.1016/j.radonc.2022.07.012
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。