通用距离移位器和距离补偿器可使当前商用质子系统实现质子笔束扫描单能布拉格峰FLASH放疗
本研究开发逆向计划工具,利用单能层质子笔束扫描结合距离回拉与距离补偿,在体模C形靶区和6例既往接受质子立体定向体部放疗的肺癌患者中比较布拉格峰法与透射法的剂量学特征和三维剂量率。布拉格峰计划靶区均匀性相当,低至中等剂量泄漏体积显著降低,6例肺癌患者单次34 GyRBE照射时肺V7GyRBE体积最多降低32%(P=0.001),但透射计划在主要危及器官的FLASH剂量率覆盖(V40GyRBE/s)较布拉格峰计划高2.4%。
要点
- 布拉格峰计划与透射计划的最小机器单位分别为1200 MU/spot和400 MU/spot,对应spot峰值剂量率分别为1950 GyRBE/s和670 GyRBE/s。
- 6例肺癌患者单次34 GyRBE照射、评估RTOG 0915约束时,布拉格峰计划肺V7GyRBE体积最多降低32%(P=0.001)。
- 透射计划在主要危及器官的FLASH剂量率覆盖(V40GyRBE/s)较布拉格峰计划高2.4%,但布拉格峰计划通过更高MU/spot和精细剂量率优化算法也可达到V40GyRBE/s的FLASH放疗阈值。
核心结论
- 本首项概念验证研究证明,结合距离回拉与强大逆向优化的新方法可利用当前可用机器参数、基于单能布拉格峰实现FLASH剂量率。
- 布拉格峰FLASH计划可维持与透射计划相似的靶区覆盖和均匀性,同时与透射计划相比大幅改善危及器官保护。
研究设计与样本
- 开发逆向计划工具,用于单能层调强质子治疗FLASH放疗计划优化。
- 计算距离回拉使单能质子束停止于靶区远端边缘,优化各野spot图与权重以利用质子束布拉格峰达到足够剂量率。
- 在体模C形靶区及6例既往接受质子立体定向体部放疗的连续肺癌患者中,分别用新布拉格峰法和透射技术制定计划,研究剂量学特征和三维剂量率。
主要发现
- 透射计划和布拉格峰计划的最小机器单位分别为400 MU/spot和1200 MU/spot,对应spot峰值剂量率分别为670 GyRBE/s和1950 GyRBE/s。
- 布拉格峰计划靶区均匀性总体相当,同时显著降低低至中等剂量水平的剂量泄漏体积。
- 6例肺癌患者单次34 GyRBE照射、评估RTOG 0915约束时,布拉格峰计划肺V7GyRBE体积最多降低32%(P=0.001)。
- 透射计划在主要危及器官的FLASH剂量率覆盖(V40GyRBE/s)较布拉格峰计划高2.4%。
- 布拉格峰计划使用更高MU/spot和精细剂量率优化算法也可达到V40GyRBE/s的FLASH放疗阈值。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
PURPOSE: Transmission beams have been proposed for ultra-high dose (or FLASH) proton planning, limiting the organ sparing potentials of proton therapy. By pulling back the ranges of the highest energy proton beams and compensating proton ranges to adapt to the target distally, the exit dose of proton beams can be eliminated to better protect organs at risk while still preserving FLASH dose rate delivery. METHOD AND MATERIALS: An inverse planning tool was developed to optimize intensity modulated proton therapy using a single-energy layer for FLASH radiation therapy planning. The range pull-backs were calculated to stop single-energy proton beams at the distal edge of the target. The spot map and weights of each field were optimized to achieve a sufficient dose rate using proton beam Bragg peaks. A C-shape target in phantom, along with 6 consecutive lung cancer patients previously treated using proton stereotactic body radiation therapy were planned using this novel Bragg Peak method and also transmission technique. Dosimetry characteristics and 3-dimensional dose rate were investigated. RESULTS: The minimum monitor units (MU) for transmission and Bragg peak plans were 400 MU/spot and 1200 MU/spot, respectively, corresponding to spot peak dose rates of 670 GyRBE (relative biological effectiveness) per second and 1950 GyRBE per second. Bragg peak plans yield a generally comparable target uniformity while significantly reducing dose spillage volume from the low to medium dose level. For all the 6 lung cases delivery of 34 GyRBE in 1 fraction, assessing Radiation Therapy Oncology Group 0915 constraints, the lung V7GyRBE volume was reduced by up to 32% (P = .001) for Bragg peak plans. The transmission plans tended to generate 2.4% higher FLASH dose rate coverage (V40GyRBE/s) versus Bragg peak plans over the major organs at risk. However, Bragg peak plans could also reach the FLASH radiation therapy threshold of V40GyRBE/s using a higher MU/spot and sophisticated dose-rate optimization algorithm. CONCLUSIONS: This first proof-of-concept study has demonstrated this novel method of combining range pull-back and powerful inverse optimization capable of achieving FLASH dose rate based on currently available machine parameters using a single-energy Bragg peak. Similar target coverage and uniformity can be maintained by Bragg peak FLASH plans while substantially improving the sparing of organs at risk compared with transmission plans.
引用
- Kang M, Wei S, Choi JI, et al. A Universal Range Shifter and Range Compensator Can Enable Proton Pencil Beam Scanning Single-Energy Bragg Peak FLASH-RT Treatment Using Current Commercially Available Proton Systems. Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys. 2022. PMID: 35101597. doi:10.1016/j.ijrobp.2022.01.009
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。