口咽癌大体肿瘤体积和高危临床靶体积磁共振引导勾画变异性的综合定量评估:一项R-IDEAL 0期前瞻性研究
该多机构研究将4例口咽癌患者的治疗模拟磁共振扫描提供给7个国际癌症中心的26名放射肿瘤科医生进行勾画,评估大体肿瘤体积、高危临床靶体积及唾液腺勾画的一致性。结果显示肿瘤和靶区勾画存在较大变异,而正常组织勾画相对一致,作者认为仍需制定适当指南、开展勾画质量保证会议和培训。
要点
- 大体肿瘤体积和高危临床靶体积的观察者间勾画变异较大。
- 正常组织勾画在重叠/距离指标上更为一致。
- 作者认为磁共振引导头颈癌放疗计划仍需指南、质量保证和培训。
核心结论
- 作者认为该研究数据提示,采用基于磁共振的头颈癌治疗计划仍需要适当的指南、勾画质量保证会议和培训。
- 作者认为此类工作应在减少勾画变异和确保不同临床实践中靶区设计标准化方面发挥关键作用。
研究设计与样本
- 研究回顾性收集了4例口咽癌患者的治疗前T1加权、T1加权钆对比剂增强和T2加权磁共振成像扫描,方案经机构审查委员会批准。
- 扫描提供给参与勾画研究的7个国际癌症中心的26名放射肿瘤科医生,同时提供患者临床病史、体格检查结果、医学照片和影像学结果。
- 采用同时真实性和性能水平估计算法及基于重叠/距离指标的轮廓两两比较进行分析。
- 参与者完成简短问卷以评估经验和临床靶体积勾画的机构实践。
主要发现
- 同时真实性和性能水平估计算法比较中,所有医生勾画的大体肿瘤原发灶、大体肿瘤淋巴结、临床靶体积原发灶和临床靶体积淋巴结的平均Dice相似系数分别为0.77、0.67、0.77和0.69。
- 两两分析中,所有医生勾画的大体肿瘤原发灶、大体肿瘤淋巴结、临床靶体积原发灶和临床靶体积淋巴结的平均Dice相似系数分别为0.67、0.60、0.67和0.58。
- 考虑重叠/距离指标时,正常组织轮廓的勾画更为一致。
- 放射肿瘤学临床经验中位数为7年,磁共振成像勾画经验中位数为3.5年。
- 7个参与机构中6个使用10 mm的大体肿瘤体积至临床靶体积外扩边界,1个机构使用8 mm,3名参与者(来自3个不同机构)使用5 mm边界。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为,采用基于磁共振的头颈癌治疗计划仍需要适当的指南、勾画质量保证会议和培训。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
PURPOSE: Tumor and target volume manual delineation remains a challenging task in head and neck cancer radiation therapy. The purpose of this study was to conduct a multi-institutional evaluation of manual delineations of gross tumor volume (GTV), high-risk clinical target volume (CTV), parotids, and submandibular glands on treatment simulation magnetic resonance scans of patients with oropharyngeal cancer. METHODS AND MATERIALS: We retrospectively collected pretreatment T1-weighted, T1-weighted with gadolinium contrast, and T2-weighted magnetic resonance imaging scans for 4 patients with oropharyngeal cancer under an institution review board-approved protocol. We provided the scans to 26 radiation oncologists from 7 international cancer centers that participated in this delineation study. We also provide the patients' clinical history and physical examination findings, along with a medical photographic image and radiologic results. We used both the Simultaneous Truth and Performance Level Estimation algorithm and pair-wise comparisons of the contours, using overlap/distance metrics. Lastly, to assess experience and CTV delineation institutional practices, we had participants complete a brief questionnaire. RESULTS: Large variability was measured between observers' delineations for GTVs and CTVs. The mean Dice similarity coefficient values across all physicians' delineations for GTVp, GTVn, CTVp, and CTVn were 0.77, 0.67, 0.77, and 0.69, respectively, for Simultaneous Truth and Performance Level Estimation algorithm comparison, and 0.67, 0.60, 0.67, and 0.58, respectively, for pair-wise analysis. Normal tissue contours were defined more consistently when considering overlap/distance metrics. The median radiation oncology clinical experience was 7 years. The median experience delineating on magnetic resonance imaging was 3.5 years. The GTV-to-CTV margin used was 10 mm for 6 of 7 participant institutions. One institution used 8 mm, and 3 participants (from 3 different institutions) used a margin of 5 mm. CONCLUSIONS: The data from this study suggests that appropriate guidelines, contouring quality assurance sessions, and training are still needed for the adoption of magnetic resonance-based treatment planning for head and neck cancers. Such efforts should play a critical role in reducing delineation variation and ensure standardization of target design across clinical practices.
引用
- Cardenas CE, Blinde SE, Mohamed ASR, et al. Comprehensive Quantitative Evaluation of Variability in Magnetic Resonance-Guided Delineation of Oropharyngeal Gross Tumor Volumes and High-Risk Clinical Target Volumes: An R-IDEAL Stage 0 Prospective Study. Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys. 2022. PMID: 35124134. doi:10.1016/j.ijrobp.2022.01.050
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。