胃癌自适应放疗中的胃变形模型:个体化与群体化策略比较
研究基于19名健康志愿者的MRI和7例胃癌患者的CT,评估个体化与群体化两种策略预测胃充盈变化所致形状改变的能力。群体化模型预测全胃和空胃形状的中位Dice相似系数分别为0.91和0.82,患者与志愿者结果相当,群体化模型优于个体化模型,可能用于胃癌计划库。
要点
- 群体化模型预测全胃形状中位Dice系数0.91,优于个体化模型的0.89。
- 群体化模型预测空胃形状中位Dice系数0.82,个体化策略因体积不可实现而失败。
- 群体化模型在患者中预测中位Dice系数0.87,与志愿者0.88相当。
核心结论
- 群体化模型优于个体化模型,能预测依赖充盈的胃形状变化,因此有潜力用于胃癌计划库。
研究设计与样本
- 对19名健康志愿者在空胃、半满胃和全胃状态下进行MRI胃勾画,用于个体化与群体化策略比较。
- 个体化策略获取半满胃到空胃的变形向量场并外推预测全胃,反向过程预测空胃。
- 群体化策略采用留一法,将18名志愿者半满胃到全胃的平均变形向量应用于剩余志愿者的半满胃以预测全胃,反向预测空胃。
- 对7例胃癌患者,将志愿者群体化模型应用于其治疗前CT,预测2-3次重复CT上的胃形状。
- 所有预测均将体积设为与真实胃体积相等。
主要发现
- 全胃预测满意,群体化模型中位Dice相似系数0.91,个体化模型0.89。
- 空胃预测较差,群体化模型中位Dice相似系数0.82,个体化策略体积不可实现。
- 群体化形状预测在患者中位Dice相似系数0.87,与志愿者0.88相当。
关键数值与推荐
- 全胃预测中位Dice相似系数:群体化0.91,个体化0.89。
- 空胃预测中位Dice相似系数:群体化0.82,个体化策略体积不可实现。
- 群体化形状预测中位Dice相似系数:患者0.87,志愿者0.88。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: To create a library of plans (LoP) for gastric cancer adaptive radiotherapy, accurate predictions of shape changes due to filling variations are essential. The ability of two strategies (personalized and population-based) to predict stomach shape based on filling was evaluated for volunteer and patient data to explore the potential for use in a LoP. MATERIALS AND METHODS: For 19 healthy volunteers, stomachs were delineated on MRIs with empty (ES), half-full (HFS) and full stomach (FS). For the personalized strategy, a deformation vector field from HFS to corresponding ES was acquired and extrapolated to predict FS. For the population-based strategy, the average deformation vectors from HFS to FS of 18 volunteers were applied to the HFS of the remaining volunteer to predict FS (leave-one-out principle); thus, predictions were made for each volunteer. Reversed processes were performed to predict ES. To validate, for seven gastric cancer patients, the volunteer population-based model was applied to their pre-treatment CT to predict stomach shape on 2-3 repeat CTs. For all predictions, volume was made equal to true stomach volume. RESULTS: FS predictions were satisfactory, with median Dice similarity coefficient (mDSC) of 0.91 (population-based) and 0.89 (personalized). ES predictions were poorer: mDSC = 0.82 for population-based; personalized strategy yielded unachievable volumes. Population-based shape predictions (both ES and FS) were comparable between patients (mDSC = 0.87) and volunteers (0.88). CONCLUSION: The population-based model outperformed the personalized model and demonstrated its ability in predicting filling-dependent stomach shape changes and, therefore, its potential for use in a gastric cancer LoP.
引用
- Bleeker M, Hulshof MCCM, Bel A, et al. Gastric deformation models for adaptive radiotherapy: Personalized vs population-based strategy. Radiother Oncol. 2021. PMID: 34861269. doi:10.1016/j.radonc.2021.11.028
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。