文献速递乳腺癌放疗放疗物理与技术

用于回顾性心脏剂量学的心脏图谱:一项关于观察者间勾画变异及其剂量学影响的多中心研究

Heart atlas for retrospective cardiac dosimetry: a multi-institutional study on interobserver contouring variations and their dosimetric impact.
PubMed 文献 · Radiat Oncol · 2021-12-20

该多中心研究开发了用于回顾性流行病学研究的心脏图谱,定义完整心脏及六个心脏结构的几何替代体积,并基于4家医院16例左侧乳腺癌3D适形切向野放疗计划评估6名观察者的勾画一致性与剂量学变异。完整心脏勾画一致性高(平均JSC 89%,体积CV 5.2%,平均剂量CV 4.2%),左前心肌JSC 63%、右前心肌JSC 58%为可接受,肺动脉瓣空间一致性低导致剂量学一致性差。作者认为基于旧影像的回顾性剂量学中几何替代体积可获更好勾画一致性,但对小结构如肺动脉瓣仍有局限。

要点

  • 完整心脏勾画一致性高:平均JSC 89%,体积CV 5.2%,平均剂量CV 4.2%
  • 左前心肌JSC 63%、右前心肌JSC 58%,勾画一致性可接受
  • 肺动脉瓣空间一致性低,导致剂量学一致性差

核心结论

  • 基于旧影像的回顾性剂量学中,心脏危及器官的几何替代体积可获得比解剖定义更好的勾画一致性,但对肺动脉瓣等小结构仍存在局限。

研究设计与样本

  • 多中心研究,收集4家医院16例左侧乳腺癌3D适形切向野放疗的治疗计划记录,6名观察者各自勾画全部患者。

主要发现

  • 完整心脏勾画一致性高:平均Jaccard相似系数(JSC)89%,体积变异系数(CV)5.2%,平均剂量CV 4.2%。
  • 左前心肌JSC 63%、体积CV 9.8%、平均剂量CV 11.9%;右前心肌JSC 58%、体积CV 11.5%、平均剂量CV 8.0%。
  • 深部结构与主动脉瓣的空间变异较高,但剂量学一致性良好;肺动脉瓣空间一致性低,剂量学一致性差。

关键数值与推荐

  • 图谱定义完整心脏及六个心脏结构的几何替代体积:主动脉瓣、肺动脉瓣、全部深部结构合并、心肌、左前心肌、右前心肌。

临床怎么用

  • 原文未据此给出推荐。

局限性

  • 原文指出,几何替代体积对肺动脉瓣等小结构仍存在局限。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

PURPOSE: Cardiac effects after breast cancer radiation therapy potentially affect more patients as survival improves. The heart's heterogeneous radiation exposure and composition of functional structures call for establishing individual relationships between structure dose and specific late effects. However, valid dosimetry requires reliable contouring which is challenging for small volumes based on older, lower-quality computed tomography imaging. We developed a heart atlas for robust heart contouring in retrospective epidemiologic studies. METHODS AND MATERIALS: The atlas defined the complete heart and geometric surrogate volumes for six cardiac structures: aortic valve, pulmonary valve, all deeper structures combined, myocardium, left anterior myocardium, and right anterior myocardium. We collected treatment planning records from 16 patients from 4 hospitals including dose calculations for 3D conformal tangential field radiation therapy for left-sided breast cancer. Six observers each contoured all patients. We assessed spatial contouring agreement and corresponding dosimetric variability. RESULTS: Contouring agreement for the complete heart was high with a mean Jaccard similarity coefficient (JSC) of 89%, a volume coefficient of variation (CV) of 5.2%, and a mean dose CV of 4.2%. The left (right) anterior myocardium had acceptable agreement with 63% (58%) JSC, 9.8% (11.5%) volume CV, and 11.9% (8.0%) mean dose CV. Dosimetric agreement for the deep structures and aortic valve was good despite higher spatial variation. Low spatial agreement for the pulmonary valve translated to poor dosimetric agreement. CONCLUSIONS: For the purpose of retrospective dosimetry based on older imaging, geometric surrogate volumes for cardiac organs at risk can yield better contouring agreement than anatomical definitions, but retain limitations for small structures like the pulmonary valve.

来源:Radiat Oncol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Stockinger M, Karle H, Rennau H, et al. Heart atlas for retrospective cardiac dosimetry: a multi-institutional study on interobserver contouring variations and their dosimetric impact. Radiat Oncol. 2021. PMID: 34930360. doi:10.1186/s13014-021-01965-5

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。