文献速递免疫规划卫生政策与健康促进

污染与纯净启动对疫苗及健康干预态度的影响:随机对照实验

Effect of contamination and purity priming on attitudes to vaccination and other health interventions: A randomised controlled experiment.
PubMed 文献 · Vaccine · 2021-10-08

该在线随机对照实验将642名成人随机分配至六种启动条件(生物污染、化学污染、纯净环境、危险标志及两类中性对照),评估污染与纯净启动对10种常规及替代健康干预措施态度的影响。结果显示启动未导致评价差异,但厌恶敏感性较高者对抗生素、手术、MMR疫苗和破伤风注射的有效性评价较低,对维生素/矿物质评价较高。

要点

  • 污染与纯净启动未改变对健康干预措施安全性和有效性的评价。
  • 厌恶敏感性高者对抗生素、手术、MMR疫苗和破伤风注射有效性评价较低。
  • 厌恶敏感性高者对维生素/矿物质有效性评价较高。

核心结论

  • 在线实验未发现污染与纯净启动对被试评价常规和替代健康干预措施安全性和有效性有实验效应。
  • 个体厌恶敏感性差异与疫苗接种及补充替代医学干预措施的态度相关。

研究设计与样本

  • 在线启动实验,采用被试间设计,包含四种实验条件(生物污染照片、化学污染照片、纯净环境照片、危险标志图标)和两种对照条件(中性场景照片、中性图标)。
  • 共642名成人完成实验,随机分配至六种条件之一,暴露于图片后对10种常规和替代健康干预措施的有效性和安全性进行评分,并使用简化版DPSS-R评估厌恶敏感性。

主要发现

  • 暴露于启动图片未导致健康干预措施评分的差异变化。
  • 厌恶敏感性较高与MMR疫苗、破伤风注射、抗生素和手术的有效性评分较低相关。
  • 厌恶敏感性较高与维生素/矿物质的有效性评分较高相关。

临床怎么用

  • 针对厌恶敏感性较高的个体,沟通疫苗等健康干预措施时应考虑其情感倾向对有效性评价的影响。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

The objective of this experiment is to assess whether priming for contamination and purity causes a change in attitudes to health interventions, including vaccination, and complementary and alternative medicines (CAMs). An online priming experiment was conducted with four between-subject experimental conditions including photos of: 1) biological contamination, 2) chemical contamination, 3) pure environments, such as pristine landscapes, and 4) hazard signs/icons indicating physical threats. Two control conditions included photos of neutral scenes and neutral icons, whereby experimental groups were compared against the related control groups (photograph for conditions 1-3 and neutral icons for condition 4). Subjects were randomly assigned to one of the six conditions, and after exposure to the images they were asked to rate 10 conventional and alternative health interventions for effectiveness and safety, as well being assessed for disgust sensitivity using the reduced-item DPSS-R [10]. A total of 642 adults completed the experiment. Exposure to primes did not cause a differential change in ratings of health interventions. Nevertheless, higher levels of sensitivity to disgust were associated with lower ratings of the effectiveness of MMR vaccination, tetanus injection, antibiotics, and surgery; and higher levels of sensitivity to disgust were associated with higher ratings of effectiveness of vitamins/minerals. In conclusion, this online experiment did not find an experimental effect of priming for contamination and purity on subjects' ratings of the safety and effectiveness of conventional and alternative health interventions. This indicates that attitudes to these health interventions are not influenced by a temporary increase in the salience of feelings of contamination or purity. However, individual differences in disgust sensitivity are related to their attitudes to vaccination and CAM interventions.

来源:Vaccine,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Bryden GM, Rockloff M, Browne M, et al. Effect of contamination and purity priming on attitudes to vaccination and other health interventions: A randomised controlled experiment. Vaccine. 2021. PMID: 34635374. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2021.09.063

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。