成人流感疫苗接种状态多源一致性研究
该研究比较了自我报告、州免疫信息系统、健康系统电子病历等多源流感疫苗接种数据的一致性。以自我报告为金标准时,与所有来源合并的一致率为85%;以PA-SIIS为金标准时,所有来源合并的灵敏度为96%。建议在高精度数据需求时采用多源三角验证。
要点
- 自我报告与州免疫信息系统均为实际接种率的好估计。
- 多源合并可提高灵敏度至96%,但特异度降至63%。
- 疫苗效果研究等高精度场景应使用多源三角验证。
核心结论
- 自我报告和PA-SIIS均为实际疫苗接种率的好估计。
- 需要高精度数据时,应使用多源三角验证。
研究设计与样本
- 比较自我报告、州免疫信息系统、健康系统电子病历及其他来源的疫苗接种数据。
- 研究对象为2016-2017至2019-2020四个季节的门诊和住院流感疫苗效果研究参与者。
主要发现
- 以自我报告为金标准,与本地EMR、PA-SIIS和所有来源的一致率分别为62%、77%和85%。
- 以PA-SIIS为金标准,与本地EMR和所有来源的一致率分别为77%和78%。
- 所有来源合并的灵敏度为96%(95% CI=95,97),特异度为63%(62,64)。
- PA-SIIS提供的验证疫苗比例最高(69.3%),EMR为43.3%,其他来源为12.4%。
- IIS对流感疫苗接种的捕获随时间未持续改善:儿童显著增加(P=0.001),工作年龄成人无变化,老年人减少(P=0.004)。
临床怎么用
- 在疫苗效果研究等需要高精度数据的场景中,应采用多源三角验证。
- 自我报告和PA-SIIS可用于估计实际疫苗接种率。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: Many vaccination studies rely on self-reported vaccination status, with its inherent biases. Accuracy of influenza vaccination self-report has been evaluated periodically, typically using the medical record as the gold standard. The burgeoning of electronic medical records (EMRs) and immunization information systems (IISs) and the rise of adult vaccine administration in community pharmacies suggest the need for a reevaluation of self-reported vaccination status. METHODS: Vaccination data from self-report, the state IIS, the health system EMR and other sources were compared for participants in outpatient and inpatient influenza vaccine effectiveness studies for four seasons (2016-2017 to 2019-2020). Agreement among the sources was calculated along with sensitivity and specificity. Tests for trend assessed changes in completeness of the Pennsylvania - Statewide IIS (PA-SIIS) data over time. RESULTS: With self-report as the gold standard, agreement with the local EMR, PA-SIIS, and all sources was 62%, 77% and 85%, respectively. Sensitivity of the EMR was 42% (95% CI = 41, 43) and specificity was 91% (90, 92). With PA-SIIS-as the gold standard, agreement with the local EMR and all sources was 77% and 78%, respectively. Sensitivity of all sources combined was 96% (95, 97) and specificity was (63% (62, 64). Capture of influenza vaccinations in the IIS has not consistently improved over time, with a significant increase among children (P = 0.001), no change among working-age adults and a decrease among older adults (P = 0.004). However, PA-SIIS provided the largest percentage of verified vaccines (69.3%) compared with EMR (43.3%) and other sources (12.4%). CONCLUSION: Both self-report and PA-SIIS are good estimates of actual vaccine uptake. When high accuracy data are required, such as for vaccine effectiveness studies, triangulation using multiple sources should be conducted.
引用
- Nowalk MP, D'Agostino HEA, Zimmerman RK, et al. Agreement among sources of adult influenza vaccination in the age of immunization information systems. Vaccine. 2021. PMID: 34716041. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2021.10.041
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。