成熟度在法国青少年HPV疫苗接种决策中的作用
研究通过定性访谈和焦点小组探讨法国青少年女孩及其母亲在HPV疫苗接种决策中成熟度的作用。研究发现青少年参与决策随成熟度演变,但多数呈被动角色,其参与不足不仅因成熟度缺乏,也因母亲和医生将其排除在外。建议采取个体化方法加强青少年与父母和医生关于HPV疫苗的讨论和信息。
要点
- 青少年HPV疫苗决策参与随成熟度演变,但多数呈被动角色。
- 青少年参与不足不仅因成熟度缺乏,也因母亲和医生将其排除。
- 疫苗犹豫母亲的观点和媒体争议可能影响女儿信念。
核心结论
- 青少年女孩参与HPV疫苗决策是一个随成熟度演变的过程。
- 多数青少年在决策中呈被动角色,跟随父母引导。
- 青少年参与不足不仅因成熟度缺乏,也因母亲和医生将其排除在外。
- 疫苗犹豫母亲的观点及主流媒体争议可能显著影响女儿自身观点和信念。
- 需要个体化方法让青少年参与自身健康决策,如加强父母和医生关于HPV疫苗的讨论和信息。
研究设计与样本
- 定性研究,对24名青少年女孩及其21名母亲进行访谈,并开展两个青少年女孩焦点小组(n=12)。
- 采用主题分析的代码本方法。
主要发现
- 青少年以不同速度走向成熟,部分表现出冲动决策等儿童特征,部分描述更理性、反思性的决策。
- 尽管存在差异,多数青少年描述在HPV疫苗接种决策中呈被动角色,跟随父母引导。
- 青少年表达了对信息和参与讨论的渴望,表明其参与不足可能不仅因成熟度缺乏,也因母亲和医生将其排除。
- 疫苗犹豫母亲的观点及主流媒体争议可能显著影响女儿自身观点和信念。
临床怎么用
- 采取个体化方法让青少年参与自身健康决策。
- 加强父母和医生关于HPV疫苗接种的讨论和信息。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Mothers are often responsible for vaccination decisions in the household. However, their confidence in certain vaccines such as Human Papillomavirus (HPV) vaccines is eroding in some countries. France is one of the countries with the lowest HPV vaccine uptake in Europe, with parents delaying or refusing the vaccine for their adolescent daughters due to safety- and effectiveness-related concerns. Although parental consent is required for vaccination, adolescents' involvement in HPV vaccination decision-making could improve vaccine uptake, with self-consent procedures already introduced in some countries. Adolescents' capacity to engage in decision-making is influenced by their maturity and autonomy in health. This study explored the role of maturity in decision-making around HPV vaccination in France through qualitative interviews with adolescent girls (n = 24) and their mothers (n = 21) and two focus groups with adolescent girls (n = 12). A codebook approach to thematic analysis revealed that adolescent girls' involvement in HPV decision-making is a process that evolved with maturity. As adolescents progressed towards maturity at different speeds, some expressed childlike traits such as impulsive decisions and others described more rational, reflective decision-making. Despite these differences, most adolescents in this study described a passive role in HPV vaccination decision-making, following their parents' lead. However, their expressed desire for information and involvement in discussions indicates that their lack of engagement may not only be due to a lack of maturity but also a result of mothers and doctors excluding them from getting involved. Furthermore, as health behaviours are shaped during adolescence, the influence of vaccine hesitant mothers on their daughters' own views and beliefs could be significant, together with exposure to regular controversies in the mainstream media. Individualised approaches to engage adolescents in decision-making around their own health are needed, for example through strengthening discussions and information around HPV vaccination with parents and doctors.
引用
- Karafillakis E, Peretti-Watel P, Verger P, et al. The role of maturity in adolescent decision-making around HPV vaccination in France. Vaccine. 2021. PMID: 34483023. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2021.08.096
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。