文献速递免疫规划传染病防控与疫情报告

纳入流感疫苗接种史的简单模型评估疫苗效果

Simple models to include influenza vaccination history when evaluating the effect of influenza vaccination.
PubMed 文献 · Euro Surveill · 2021-01-01

该研究采用检测阴性设计,纳入2011/12至2018/19八个流感季共10356人,评估考虑接种史的流感疫苗效果(EIV)。结果显示,当季接种且既往未接种、既往1-2剂和3-5剂者的EIV分别为50%、45%和38%,仅既往接种1-2剂和3-5剂者为30%和43%。作者建议疫苗效果研究应考虑既往接种史,因其可保留效果且常为效应修饰因子。

要点

  • 当季接种者中,既往接种剂次越多,当季疫苗效果估计值越低。
  • 仅既往接种者仍有保护效果,不应简单归入未接种组。
  • 既往至少3季接种可使当季疫苗效果总体降低12个百分点。

核心结论

  • 流感疫苗效果研究应考虑既往接种史,因其可保留效果且常为效应修饰因子。
  • 将仅既往接种者归入未接种组会平均低估EIV 9个百分点(31% vs 40%)。

研究设计与样本

  • 采用检测阴性设计,纳入2011/12至2018/19八个流感季共10356名接种史记录完整者。
  • 评估当季接种联合既往接种剂次对EIV的影响,并比较不同参照组定义对估计值的影响。

主要发现

  • 当季接种且既往未接种、既往1-2剂和3-5剂者的EIV分别为50%、45%和38%。
  • 仅既往接种1-2剂和3-5剂者的EIV分别为30%和43%。
  • 既往至少3季接种使当季疫苗效果总体降低12个百分点,门诊患者降低31个百分点,9-65岁人群降低22个百分点,乙型流感降低23个百分点。
  • 将仅既往接种者归入未接种组平均低估EIV 9个百分点(31% vs 40%)。
  • 考虑既往3季或5季接种的估计值相似。

临床怎么用

  • 疫苗效果评估中应将接种状态分为当季接种、仅既往接种和未接种三类以反映完整EIV。
  • 分析时需考虑既往接种史作为效应修饰因子,避免将仅既往接种者归入参照组。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BackgroundMost reports of influenza vaccine effectiveness consider current-season vaccination only.AimWe evaluated a method to estimate the effect of influenza vaccinations (EIV) considering vaccination history.MethodsWe used a test-negative design with well-documented vaccination history to evaluate the average EIV over eight influenza seasons (2011/12-2018/19; n = 10,356). Modifying effect was considered as difference in effects of vaccination in current and previous seasons and current-season vaccination only. We also explored differences between current-season estimates excluding from the reference category people vaccinated in any of the five previous seasons and estimates without this exclusion or only for one or three previous seasons.ResultsThe EIV was 50%, 45% and 38% in people vaccinated in the current season who had previously received none, one to two and three to five doses, respectively, and it was 30% and 43% for one to two and three to five prior doses only. Vaccination in at least three previous seasons reduced the effect of current-season vaccination by 12 percentage points overall, 31 among outpatients, 22 in 9-65 year-olds, and 23 against influenza B. Including people vaccinated in previous seasons only in the unvaccinated category underestimated EIV by 9 percentage points on average (31% vs 40%). Estimates considering vaccination of three or five previous seasons were similar.ConclusionsVaccine effectiveness studies should consider influenza vaccination in previous seasons, as it can retain effect and is often an effect modifier. Vaccination status in three categories (current season, previous seasons only, unvaccinated) reflects the whole EIV.

来源:Euro Surveill,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Martínez-Baz I, Navascués A, Casado I, et al. Simple models to include influenza vaccination history when evaluating the effect of influenza vaccination. Euro Surveill. 2021. PMID: 34387185. doi:10.2807/1560-7917.ES.2021.26.32.2001099

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。