疫苗接接种者到达接种点的成本系统综述:覆盖难以触及人群的增量成本
该系统综述检索PubMed和免疫交付成本目录(IDCC),识别疫苗接接种者到达所有接种点相关成本的估算,包括培训、人力与激励、受益者定位和差旅成本,并评估其中是否有针对难以触及人群的特异性成本。结果显示,平均培训成本为每名接种或目标人员0.67美元(SD 0.94)或每剂0.10美元(SD 0.07),人力与激励成本平均每剂2.15美元(SD 2.08),受益者定位成本平均每人19.69美元(SD 26.65),差旅成本平均每剂0.07美元(SD 0.03);仅8项研究描述了难以触及人群,其中2项报告每剂增量成本为常规成本的1.3-2倍。结论是需要更多比较性成本研究,以帮助免疫规划规划者和决策者更好地分配资源。
要点
- 疫苗接接种者培训成本平均每名接种或目标人员0.67美元(SD 0.94),每剂0.10美元(SD 0.07)。
- 人力与激励成本平均每剂2.15美元(SD 2.08),受益者定位成本平均每人19.69美元(SD 26.65)。
- 覆盖难以触及人群的每剂增量成本为常规成本的1.3-2倍,培训增量成本0.02美元/剂,人力增量成本0.16-1.17美元/剂。
核心结论
- 需要更多比较性成本研究来理解疫苗接接种者到达服务难以触及人群的接种点的潜在差异成本,以帮助免疫规划规划者和决策者更好地分配资源。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述,检索PubMed和免疫交付成本目录(IDCC)于2019年,识别疫苗接接种者到达所有接种点相关成本的估算,并基于供应侧障碍框架评估成本是否针对难以触及人群。
主要发现
- 共找到19项研究描述疫苗接接种者平均培训成本为每名接种或目标人员0.67美元(SD 0.94)和每剂0.10美元(SD 0.07)。
- 29项研究中疫苗接接种者人力与激励成本平均每剂2.15美元(SD 2.08)。
- 13项研究描述疫苗接接种者了解受益者位置的干预成本,平均每人19.69美元(SD 26.65)。
- 6项研究描述疫苗接接种者差旅成本,平均每剂0.07美元(SD 0.03)。
- 仅8项研究描述了难以触及人群,其中2项检查每剂增量成本,为常规成本的1.3-2倍;培训增量成本为每剂0.02美元,针对难以触及人群的人力增量成本为每剂0.16-1.17美元。
关键数值与推荐
- 疫苗接接种者培训成本:每名接种或目标人员0.67美元(SD 0.94),每剂0.10美元(SD 0.07)。
- 疫苗接接种者人力与激励成本:每剂2.15美元(SD 2.08)。
- 疫苗接接种者了解受益者位置的干预成本:每人19.69美元(SD 26.65)。
- 疫苗接接种者差旅成本:每剂0.07美元(SD 0.03)。
- 难以触及人群的每剂增量成本为常规成本的1.3-2倍;培训增量成本每剂0.02美元,人力增量成本每剂0.16-1.17美元。
临床怎么用
- 免疫规划规划者和决策者可参考这些成本估算,在扩展免疫覆盖至难以触及人群时进行资源分配和预算规划。
局限性
- 仅8项研究描述了难以触及人群,其中仅2项检查了增量成本,需要更多比较性成本研究来理解差异成本。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: Economic evidence on how much it may cost for vaccinators to reach populations is important to plan vaccination programs. Moreover, knowing the incremental costs to reach populations that have traditionally been undervaccinated, especially those hard-to-reach who are facing supply-side barriers to vaccination, is essential to expanding immunization coverage to these populations. METHODS: We conducted a systematic review to identify estimates of costs associated with getting vaccinators to all vaccination sites. We searched PubMed and the Immunization Delivery Cost Catalogue (IDCC) in 2019 for the following costs to vaccinators: (1) training costs; (2) labor costs, per diems, and incentives; (3) identification of vaccine beneficiary location; and (4) travel costs. We assessed if any of these costs were specific to populations that are hard-to-reach for vaccination, based on a framework for examining supply-side barriers to vaccination. RESULTS: We found 19 studies describing average vaccinator training costs at $0.67/person vaccinated or targeted (SD $0.94) and $0.10/dose delivered (SD $0.07). The average cost for vaccinator labor and incentive costs across 29 studies was $2.15/dose (SD $2.08). We identified 13 studies describing intervention costs for a vaccinator to know the location of a beneficiary, with an average cost of $19.69/person (SD $26.65), and six studies describing vaccinator travel costs, with an average cost of $0.07/dose (SD $0.03). Only eight of these studies described hard-to-reach populations for vaccination; two studies examined incremental costs per dose to reach hard-to-reach populations, which were 1.3-2 times higher than the regular costs. The incremental cost to train vaccinators was $0.02/dose, and incremental labor costs for targeting hard-to-reach populations were $0.16-$1.17/dose. CONCLUSION: Additional comparative costing studies are needed to understand the potential differential costs for vaccinators reaching the vaccination sites that serve hard-to-reach populations. This will help immunization program planners and decision-makers better allocate resources to extend vaccination programs.
引用
- Ozawa S, Yemeke TT, Mitgang E, et al. Systematic review of the costs for vaccinators to reach vaccination sites: Incremental costs of reaching hard-to-reach populations. Vaccine. 2021. PMID: 34238610. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2021.05.019
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。