法国医院医师的疫苗犹豫:2019年横断面调查
研究在法国14家公立医院对1795名医院医师进行横断面调查,发现93.7%强烈支持疫苗接种,但42.2%(95CI=39.8-44.6)存在中度疫苗犹豫。感染病专科医师疫苗犹豫率最低(12.3%;95CI=6.7-21.3),儿科医师为27.7%(95CI=21.4-35.2)。疫苗犹豫者更不信任疫苗信息来源,且更少接种季节性流感疫苗、推荐疫苗或说服犹豫患者接种。
要点
- 法国医院医师中93.7%强烈支持疫苗接种,但42.2%存在中度疫苗犹豫。
- 感染病专科医师疫苗犹豫率最低(12.3%),儿科医师为27.7%。
- 疫苗犹豫者更少接种流感疫苗、推荐疫苗或说服患者接种。
核心结论
- 强烈支持疫苗接种并不能防止疫苗犹豫,疫苗犹豫在大多数专科中均有观察到。
- 需要干预措施帮助犹豫的医院医师采取更主动的疫苗接种实践。
研究设计与样本
- 共纳入1795名医院医师(参与率86%),数据按年龄和性别加权。
- 采用凝聚层次聚类分析识别疫苗犹豫医师,并使用多重泊松回归研究相关因素。
主要发现
- 93.7%的医院医师强烈支持疫苗接种,但42.2%(95CI=39.8-44.6)存在中度疫苗犹豫。
- 疫苗犹豫率在感染病专科医师中最低(12.3%;95CI=6.7-21.3),儿科医师为27.7%(95CI=21.4-35.2)。
- 犹豫的医师更不信任疫苗信息来源,更常怀疑疫苗安全性。
- 相比非犹豫医师,高疫苗犹豫者更少参加过疫苗接种医学课程、更少接种季节性流感疫苗、更少向患者推荐疫苗、更少尝试说服犹豫患者接种。
临床怎么用
- 医院医师应意识到自身疫苗犹豫可能影响患者接种推荐和说服行为。
- 针对疫苗犹豫医师的干预应侧重提升疫苗安全信息信任和主动推荐实践。
局限性
- 横断面设计无法确定因果关系。
- 研究仅在法国公立医院医师中进行,外推需谨慎。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Healthcare professionals, because they recommend vaccines to their patients, answer their questions, and vaccinate them, are the cornerstone of vaccination in France. They can nonetheless be affected by vaccine hesitancy (VH). AIMS: We sought to study the opinions, practices, and perceptions of French hospital staff physicians (HSPs) toward vaccination and the prevalence and correlates of VH among them. METHODS: We conducted a cross-sectional survey in 14 public hospitals in France from September 2018 to October 2019. HSPs completed a standardized questionnaire -most of the time face-to-face - about their vaccine-related attitudes and practices. Data were weighted for age and sex. An agglomerative hierarchical cluster analysis of the HSPs' perceptions and opinions toward vaccination allowed us to identify vaccine-hesitant HSPs, and multiple Poisson regression with robust standard errors let us study the factors associated with VH. RESULTS: The study included 1,795 HSPs (participation rate: 86%). Almost all (93.7%) were strongly favorable to vaccination, even though 42.2% (95CI = 39.8-44.6) showed moderate VH. VH prevalence was lowest among infectious disease specialists (12.3%; 95CI = 6.7-21.3) and pediatricians (27.7%; 95CI = 21.4-35.2). Hesitant HSPs were less trustful of vaccination information sources and doubted the safety of vaccines more often than HSPs with almost no VH. Compared with non-hesitant HSPs, those with higher VH had less often taken a medical course about vaccination and were less likely to be vaccinated against seasonal influenza, to recommend vaccines to their patients and to try to convince vaccine-hesitant patients to be vaccinated. CONCLUSIONS: Strong favorability to vaccination does not prevent VH, which was observed in most specialties. Interventions are required to help hesitant HSPs to adopt more proactive vaccination practices.
引用
- Verger P, Dualé C, Lenzi N, et al. Vaccine hesitancy among hospital staff physicians: A cross-sectional survey in France in 2019. Vaccine. 2021. PMID: 34210575. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2021.06.053
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。