确定改善被监禁人群健康的研究优先级:澳大利亚监狱公民陪审团结果
该卫生政策论文采用审议式研究方法,在澳大利亚六所监狱(三所男监、三所女监)开展公民陪审团,让被监禁者确定其健康研究优先事项。所有陪审团均将心理健康列为第一研究优先事项,多数陪审团还确定了监狱医疗服务、酒精及其他药物使用、教育和传染病等优先领域。
要点
- 被监禁者通过公民陪审团直接参与确定其健康研究优先事项。
- 所有六所监狱的陪审团一致将心理健康列为第一研究优先事项。
- 多数陪审团将监狱医疗服务、酒精及其他药物使用、教育和传染病列为优先领域。
核心结论
- 被监禁者认为心理健康是其健康研究的首要优先事项。
- 监狱医疗服务、酒精及其他药物使用、教育和传染病被多数陪审团确定为研究优先领域。
- 若研究优先事项设定要考虑健康公平目标,需纳入健康受影响最严重公民的观点。
研究设计与样本
- 采用审议式研究方法,在澳大利亚六所监狱(三所男监、三所女监)开展公民陪审团。
- 参与者通过监狱内分发的意向表达表选拔,观看专家预录信息后审议最多4小时,就五项研究优先事项达成一致。
主要发现
- 所有公民陪审团均将心理健康列为第一研究优先事项。
- 多数公民陪审团将监狱医疗服务、酒精及其他药物使用、教育和传染病确定为研究优先事项。
关键数值与推荐
- 优先事项内的焦点包括严重精神疾病、悲伤与创伤、药物管理、医疗服务可及性、质量与资源、戒毒与同伴支持、监狱针具交换项目以及健康与生活技能教育。
临床怎么用
- 研究优先事项设定应纳入被监禁者的观点,以促进健康公平。
- 针对被监禁人群的健康干预和研究应优先关注心理健康。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Health disparities in incarcerated populations should guide investment in the health care and research of these communities. Although users of health-care services are important in providing input into decisions about research, the voices of people in prison are absent regarding research into their health. In this Health Policy paper, we present priorities for research into the health of people in prison according to people in prison themselves. By use of a deliberative research approach, citizens' juries were conducted in six prisons (three men's and three women's prisons) in Australia. Participants were selected following submissions of expression of interest forms that were distributed within the prisons. Prerecorded information by experts in the health of incarcerated people was shown to participants. Participants deliberated for up to 4 h before agreeing on five research priorities. All citizens' juries endorsed mental health as a number one research priority. Prison health-care services, alcohol and other drug use, education, and infectious diseases were identified as research priorities by most citizens' juries. Focal points within priorities included serious mental illness; grief and trauma; medication management; health-care service access, quality, and resources; drug withdrawal and peer support; prison-based needle and syringe programmes; and health and life skills education. If endeavours in research priority setting are to consider health equity goals, the views of our most health affected citizens need to be included.
引用
- Simpson PL, Guthrie J, Jones J, et al. Identifying research priorities to improve the health of incarcerated populations: results of citizens' juries in Australian prisons. Lancet Public Health. 2021. PMID: 34115972. doi:10.1016/S2468-2667(21)00050-5
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。