疫苗接种相关健康不公平:影响因素证据图与干预系统综述
共纳入413项因素研究,仅2项干预试验,证据确定性极低。
要点
- 413项研究描述P2ROGRESS等因素与VPD住院/死亡的关联,干预试验仅2项。
- 最常研究的因素为年龄(89%)、基础疾病(42%)和性别(34%)。
- 两项干预试验证据确定性极低,分别涉及员工疫苗政策和护士普遍接种。
核心结论
- 关于P2ROGRESS等因素与VPD住院和死亡关联的研究数量多,但评估干预效果的研究极少。
- 仅有的两项干预试验证据确定性极低,提示需更多高质量研究评估减少疫苗不公平的干预措施。
研究设计与样本
- 主要结局为VPD相关住院和死亡,次要结局包括疫苗获取、暴露、易感性、严重性和后果的差异。
主要发现
- 共纳入413项报告P2ROGRESS等因素的研究。
- 最常研究的因素为年龄(n=374,89%)、基础疾病(n=179,42%)和性别认同或生理性别(n=144,34%)。
- 仅识别出2项干预试验:一项(n=1249)评估员工疫苗政策对私人养老院居民流感住院和死亡的影响,证据确定性极低。
- 另一项(n未报告)评估诊所护士普遍接种对比医生接种或无干预对轮状病毒胃肠炎住院的影响,证据确定性极低。
临床怎么用
- NACI制定疫苗推荐时可参考本证据图系统识别与VPD住院和死亡不公平相关的因素。
- 其他类似组织可借鉴此方法系统梳理健康不公平证据以支持疫苗项目推荐。
局限性
- 仅2项干预试验,且证据确定性极低,无法对干预效果得出可靠结论。
- 因素研究多为描述性关联,未评估干预措施减少不公平的效果。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: The National Advisory Committee on Immunization (NACI) makes recommendations for vaccines in Canada. To inform considerations for equity when making recommendations, the NACI Secretariat developed a matrix of factors that may influence vaccine equity. To inform the matrix we mapped the evidence for P2ROGRESS And Other factors potentially associated with unequal levels of illness or death from vaccine-preventable diseases (VPDs) and systematically reviewed the evidence for interventions aimed at reducing inequities. METHODS: In October 2019 we searched Medline, Embase, and CINAHL. Two reviewers agreed on the included studies. Our primary outcomes were VPD-related hospitalizations and deaths. Secondary outcomes were differential vaccine access, and exposure, susceptibility, severity, and consequences of VPDs. Two reviewers appraised the certainty of evidence. We mapped the evidence for P2ROGRESS And Other factors and summarized the findings descriptively. We summarized the interventions narratively. RESULTS: We identified 413 studies reporting on P2ROGRESS And Other factors. The most commonly investigated factors included age (n = 374, 89%), pre-existing conditions (n = 179, 42%), and gender identity or sex (n = 144, 34%). We identified 2 trials investigating the effects of interventions. One (n = 1249) provided very low certainty evidence that staff vaccination policies may reduce hospitalizations and deaths from influenza among private care home residents. The other (n not reported) provided very low certainty evidence that universal vaccination by nurses in clinics may reduce hospitalizations for rotavirus gastroenteritis compared with vaccination by physicians or no intervention. CONCLUSIONS: There is a large body of studies reporting on hospitalizations and deaths from VPDs stratified by P2ROGRESS And Other factors. We found only two trials examining the effects of interventions on hospitalization for or mortality from VPDs. This review has been helpful to NACI and will be helpful to similar organizations aiming to systematically identify and target health inequities through the development of vaccine program recommendations.
引用
- Gates A, Rahman S, Sim S, et al. Health inequities related to vaccination: An evidence map of potentially influential factors and systematic review of interventions. Vaccine. 2021. PMID: 34092425. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2021.05.054
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。