日本医护人员院系大学生麻疹与风疹抗体滴度衰减研究(2015-2018)
该研究纳入日本茨城县立保健医疗大学1996年4月2日至2000年4月1日出生的学生,麻疹177例、风疹114例,均需追加免疫且具备追加免疫日期与前后抗体数据。采用酶免疫法测IgG抗体,回归分析显示麻疹抗体单调线性衰减,风疹抗体呈高阶线性模型并收敛于19.2。麻疹前抗体滴度15时接种后快速升至26,随后每日衰减0.014,约704天后低于保护水平16;风疹则可在平均水平下长期维持保护。
要点
- 麻疹抗体接种后单调衰减,前滴度15者约704天后降至保护水平16以下。
- 风疹抗体呈高阶线性模型,平均前滴度下收敛下限为19.2,保护可长期维持。
- 疾病接近消除时,可能需每隔数年追加接种以维持保护水平。
核心结论
- 麻疹抗体接种后单调衰减,风疹抗体则收敛于19.2并长期维持保护,二者衰减速度差异可能反映各自疾病流行情况。
- 疾病接近消除时,为维持保护水平,可能需每隔数年追加接种。
研究设计与样本
- 研究纳入日本茨城县立保健医疗大学1996年4月2日至2000年4月1日出生的学生,麻疹177例、风疹114例,均为需追加免疫且具备追加免疫日期及前后抗体数据者。
- 采用酶免疫法检测IgG抗体,将免疫后抗体滴度对免疫前滴度及接种至评估间期函数进行回归,函数依据调整决定系数选择。
主要发现
- 麻疹仅间期的线性项或对数项显著,无二次项,抗体呈单调衰减。
- 麻疹前抗体滴度15时,接种后快速升至26,随后每日衰减0.014,约704天后低于保护水平16。
- 风疹选用五阶线性模型,免疫后滴度收敛于19.2;前接种滴度取平均值时,下限为19.2。
关键数值与推荐
- 麻疹保护水平滴度为16。
- 麻疹前抗体滴度15时,接种后滴度升至26,每日衰减0.014,约704天后低于16。
- 风疹免疫后滴度收敛值为19.2,平均前接种滴度下下限为19.2。
临床怎么用
- 对麻疹抗体接近保护水平者,可依据衰减速度评估追加接种时机。
- 风疹抗体在平均前滴度下可长期维持保护,追加接种需求相对较低。
- 在疾病接近消除地区,可考虑每隔数年追加接种以维持群体保护水平。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: In Japan, measles elimination was confirmed in March 2015. Nevertheless, some outbreaks with cases imported from abroad were reported even after certification. A large rubella outbreak has been occurring since 2017. This study examines measurement of the speed of attenuation of antibody titer for a measles virus comparison with rubella virus. METHOD: Student subjects born from April 2, 1996 through April 1, 2000 were selected at Ibaraki Prefectural University of Health Sciences for this study: 177 for measles and 114 for rubella. They had available dates of additional immunization and antibodies in the following period and were judged as requiring additional immunization. We used enzyme immunoassay for IgG antibody testing. We regressed post-antibody titers of measles or rubella on pre-antibody titers and functions of duration between inoculation to post-evaluation. Functions of duration were selected according to the adjusted coefficient of determination. RESULTS: For measles, only a linear term of duration or log of duration was found to be significant without the quadratic terms. For rubella, we selected a five-order linear model which indicated that titer after vaccination would converge to 19.2. DISCUSSION: Results demonstrate that measles antibody decreased monotonically. If the pre-antibody titer was 15, vaccination raised titer quickly to 26; then it attenuated by 0.014 per day. Antibody titer is expected to be less than 16, which is the protection level of titer, after 704 days. For rubella, however, when pre-vaccination titer was evaluated at its average, the lower limit was 19.2. Therefore, protection can be maintained for a long time. This difference might reflect some circumstances of outbreaks of the respective diseases. CONCLUSION: This report describes the speed of attenuation and the epidemiological situation. The speed of attenuation can be expected to rise. Therefore, additional vaccination every several years might be necessary to maintain a protection level if a disease is almost eliminated.
引用
- Kurita J, Uematsu T, Sakurai N, et al. Attenuation of antibody titer of measles and rubella virus among university students of department of healthcare providers during 2015-2018 in Japan. Vaccine. 2021. PMID: 34120763. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2021.05.040
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。