利用现有系统综述制定疫苗接种建议:国际专家研讨会成果
国家免疫技术咨询小组(NITAG)制定免疫建议时推荐使用系统综述,但资源不足。
要点
- 注册库应包含批判性评价评级、通俗语言摘要、关键词搜索和数据可视化功能。
- 综述是否过时由使用者而非注册库工作人员决定,注册库可突出文献检索日期。
- 在线课程应针对不同受众定制内容,包含综述概览和NITAG使用现有综述的案例。
核心结论
- 专家研讨会就利用现有系统综述制定疫苗接种建议的方法达成共识,支持注册库和在线课程的关键功能设计。
主要发现
- 参与者支持注册库包含批判性评价评级、通俗语言摘要、关键词搜索和数据可视化功能。
- 参与者建议在线课程内容针对不同受众定制,并将综述概览作为主题。
- 参与者同意综述是否过时由使用者决定,注册库可突出文献检索日期或纳入原始研究的日期。
- 参与者推荐可视化功能以突出综述间的重叠,并提供处理使用综述挑战的指导。
- 未就注册库中综述使用何种批判性评价工具达成共识,但多数参与者希望注册库工作人员进行评价。
关键数值与推荐
- 注册库应包含批判性评价评级、通俗语言摘要、关键词搜索和数据可视化功能。
- 综述是否过时由使用者决定,注册库可突出文献检索日期或纳入原始研究的日期。
- 在线课程应针对不同受众定制内容,包含综述概览和NITAG使用现有综述的案例。
- 未就批判性评价工具达成共识,但多数参与者希望注册库工作人员进行评价。
临床怎么用
- NITAG可利用现有系统综述制定免疫建议,注册库和在线课程将提供检索和使用指导。
- 使用者应自行判断综述是否过时,并参考注册库突出的文献检索日期。
- 在线课程可帮助不同受众学习如何使用现有系统综述。
局限性
- 未就注册库中综述使用何种批判性评价工具达成共识。
- 注册库和在线课程计划于2020年启动,启动前将进行形成性研究。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
National immunization technical advisory groups (NITAGs) develop immunization-related recommendations. Systematic reviews are recommended to be used in this process, but conducting them requires significant resources, which many NITAGs lack. Using existing systematic reviews could help address this problem. The Robert Koch Institute and collaborators set up the SYSVAC2 project to facilitate the retrieval of existing systematic reviews and offer guidance on using them. This will include an online registry of systematic reviews relevant to immunization policy and an online course on how to use existing reviews. This report describes an international expert workshop held in December 2019 to develop consensus on methods for using existing reviews and other relevant factors for the registry and course. Members from NITAGs representing different regions of the world presented their experiences of using systematic reviews and reflected on challenges inhibiting use. Three methodologists considered different aspects of using systematic reviews. Interactive sessions followed, where implications for SYSVAC2 were discussed. Participants supported having critical appraisal ratings, plain language summaries, keyword search, and data visualization functions in the registry. They suggested tailoring course content to different audiences and including overviews of reviews as a topic and examples of how NITAGs have used or could use existing reviews. Participants agreed that whether a review is out-of-date should be decided by those using the review rather than registry staff. The registry could help by highlighting the date of literature search or included primary studies. Participants recommended a visualization function to highlight overlap across reviews and guidance on handling challenges to using reviews, ideally, involving a practical element. No consensus was reached on which critical appraisal tool to use for reviews in the registry, but a majority of participants wanted registry staff to perform appraisals. Formative research is planned before the registry and online course are launched in 2020.
引用
- Jo CL, Burchett H, Bastías M, et al. Using existing systematic reviews for developing vaccination recommendations: Results of an international expert workshop. Vaccine. 2021. PMID: 33965256. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2021.04.045
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。