儿童疫苗犹豫的多领域叙事综述
本文采用改编自「知识、理解与探究通才轮」的多维框架,从儿童与家庭、临床医生、卫生系统与政策、传染病与疫苗四个领域及跨领域因素分析儿童疫苗犹豫的促进与阻碍因素。综述识别了情绪困扰、既往负性体验与误解、临床医生态度与动机、卫生系统执行与监测不足、信息传播不畅及错误信息监测不足等因素,并提出各领域及跨领域的循证缓解策略,以补充和支持WHO全球疫苗行动计划。
要点
- 儿童疫苗犹豫受儿童与家庭、临床医生、卫生系统与政策、传染病与疫苗四领域因素影响。
- 情绪困扰、既往负性体验和误解是儿童与家庭疫苗犹豫的重要促成因素。
- 临床医生的态度与动机是疫苗犹豫的关键因素,跨领域因素强调医患关系与信息掌握。
核心结论
- 儿童疫苗犹豫是一个多领域问题,需采用协调的多领域策略加以缓解。
- 基于多维框架的循证策略可有效应对各领域及跨领域的疫苗犹豫因素。
研究设计与样本
- 叙事综述,采用改编自「知识、理解与探究通才轮」的多维框架分析儿童疫苗犹豫。
- 纳入文献超出世界卫生组织全球疫苗行动计划(WHO GVAP)所涵盖的范围。
主要发现
- 儿童与家庭领域的疫苗犹豫促成因素包括情绪困扰、既往负性体验和误解。
- 临床医生领域的疫苗犹豫由态度和动机所支撑。
- 卫生系统在缺乏执行、细致监测和透明度时促成疫苗犹豫。
- 疾病及相关疫苗信息传播效率低下以及错误信息监测不足加剧疫苗犹豫。
- 跨领域因素凸显临床医生、儿童与家长之间的关系、临床医生信息掌握、资源优先配置和公平性在应对疫苗犹豫中的作用。
临床怎么用
- 运用多领域框架识别儿童疫苗犹豫的具体促成因素并制定协调策略。
- 针对各领域及跨领域因素实施已被证明有效的循证干预措施。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Vaccine hesitancy, where individuals delay or refuse some or all vaccines, is a perennial problem. It undermines the success of the immunisation programmes and places the society, especially vulnerable populations such as children, at risk of contracting infectious diseases. The phenomenon has been extensively analysed based on four aspects - confidence, complacency, convenience and costs. We suggest the alternative use of a multi-dimensional framework adapted from the "Generalist Wheel of Knowledge, Understanding and Inquiry" that was developed by Prof Larry Green and Kurt Stange, to assess the multiple facilitators and barriers towards vaccine hesitancy in childhood vaccination. The framework identifies domains in the healthcare system namely the child and parent/family, the clinician, the healthcare system and policy, and the infectious disease and corresponding vaccine that influence vaccine hesitancy. This narrative review includes literature beyond those covered by the World health Organisation Global Vaccine Action Plan (WHO GVAP). It identifies emotional distress, past negative experience and misconceptions that contribute to vaccine hesitancy in children and family, while attitude and motivation underpin vaccine hesitancy in clinicians. The healthcare system contributes to vaccine hesitancy when enforcements, diligent monitoring and transparency are absent or lacking. Inefficient dissemination of information about the disease and its associated vaccine as well as inadequate surveillance of misinformation add to vaccine hesitancy. The inter-domain factors highlight the roles of relationship between the clinician, child and parent, information mastery of the clinician, prioritisation of resources and equity in combating vaccine hesitancy. Using this framework, we present evidence-based strategies which have been effective in mitigating vaccine hesitancy for each domain and their corresponding inter-domains. By providing new perspectives of a complex problem and its potential solutions, this narrative review aims to complement and support the WHO GVAP by developing a coordinated multi-domain strategy to mitigate vaccine hesitancy in childhood.
引用
- Hasnan S, Tan NC. Multi-domain narrative review of vaccine hesitancy in childhood. Vaccine. 2021. PMID: 33750590. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2021.02.057
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。