社交与物理距离措施对英格兰COVID-19活动的影响:多层级监测系统的发现
英国在COVID-19疫情早期采用基于流感监测的多层级监测系统,并于2020年3月23日实施强制社交与物理距离措施(SPDM)。本研究利用2020年第18周前的国家人口调查、网络指标、症状监测、哨点拭子、呼吸道暴发、二级护理入院和死亡指标,比较监测指标峰值时间与SPDM引入的时间关系。结果显示,SPDM的影响在1周内可通过人口调查、网络搜索指标和按发病日期报告的哨点拭子检测到,而对不同监测指标的影响时间从2天到4周不等。
要点
- SPDM的影响在1周内可通过社区监测指标(人口调查、网络搜索、哨点拭子)检测到。
- 对呼吸困难、流感样疾病和COVID-19编码的症状监测影响分别在2天、7天和12天检测到。
- 对住院和重症监护入院的影响均为12天,实验室阳性14天,死亡17天,养老院暴发4周。
核心结论
- SPDM对COVID-19活动的影响可在1周内通过社区监测指标检测到,凸显其在早期发现活动变化中的重要性。
- 社区拭子监测作为特异性指标可能日益重要,尤其是季节性呼吸道病毒传播增加时。
研究设计与样本
- 采用基于流感监测的多层级监测系统,数据来源包括国家人口调查、网络指标、症状监测、哨点拭子、呼吸道暴发、二级护理入院和死亡指标,时间从疫情开始至2020年第18周。
- 通过识别监测指标峰值时间相对于SPDM引入的时间,并与症状发作到不同疾病阶段和护理水平的中位时间进行比较。
主要发现
- SPDM的影响在1周内通过人口调查、网络搜索指标和按发病日期报告的哨点拭子检测到。
- 对呼吸困难、流感样疾病和COVID-19编码的症状监测指标影响分别在2天、7天和12天检测到。
- 对住院和重症监护入院的影响均为12天,实验室阳性14天,死亡17天,养老院暴发4周。
临床怎么用
- 社区监测指标(如人口调查、网络搜索、哨点拭子)可用于早期评估公共卫生干预措施(如SPDM)对COVID-19活动的影响。
- 在季节性呼吸道病毒传播增加时,社区拭子监测可作为特异性指标,辅助监测COVID-19活动变化。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BackgroundA multi-tiered surveillance system based on influenza surveillance was adopted in the United Kingdom in the early stages of the coronavirus disease (COVID-19) epidemic to monitor different stages of the disease. Mandatory social and physical distancing measures (SPDM) were introduced on 23 March 2020 to attempt to limit transmission.AimTo describe the impact of SPDM on COVID-19 activity as detected through the different surveillance systems.MethodsData from national population surveys, web-based indicators, syndromic surveillance, sentinel swabbing, respiratory outbreaks, secondary care admissions and mortality indicators from the start of the epidemic to week 18 2020 were used to identify the timing of peaks in surveillance indicators relative to the introduction of SPDM. This timing was compared with median time from symptom onset to different stages of illness and levels of care or interactions with healthcare services.ResultsThe impact of SPDM was detected within 1 week through population surveys, web search indicators and sentinel swabbing reported by onset date. There were detectable impacts on syndromic surveillance indicators for difficulty breathing, influenza-like illness and COVID-19 coding at 2, 7 and 12 days respectively, hospitalisations and critical care admissions (both 12 days), laboratory positivity (14 days), deaths (17 days) and nursing home outbreaks (4 weeks).ConclusionThe impact of SPDM on COVID-19 activity was detectable within 1 week through community surveillance indicators, highlighting their importance in early detection of changes in activity. Community swabbing surveillance may be increasingly important as a specific indicator, should circulation of seasonal respiratory viruses increase.
引用
- Bernal JL, Sinnathamby MA, Elgohari S, et al. The impact of social and physical distancing measures on COVID-19 activity in England: findings from a multi-tiered surveillance system. Euro Surveill. 2021. PMID: 33739255. doi:10.2807/1560-7917.ES.2021.26.11.2001062
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。