28个欧洲国家疫苗接种信念的社会风险放大与「可能疫苗损害」分型
基于2019年3月Eurobarometer 91.2调查的欧盟27国及英国代表性样本,通过探索性聚类分析识别出三种疫苗接种信念类型:犹豫型(约11%)、自信型(约59%)和权衡型(约29%)。公众对显著疫苗风险的信念普遍存在,且权衡型与自信型接种史相似,提示信念之外的其他因素在驱动接种行为。
要点
- 约十分之一欧盟27国及英国人群认为疫苗未严格检测即获批。
- 约三分之一认为疫苗可过载或削弱免疫系统并致病。
- 近半数认为疫苗可致严重副作用,权衡型与自信型接种史相似。
核心结论
- 公众对显著疫苗风险的信念普遍存在,「可能疫苗损害」的社会正常性得到确认。
- 沟通运动应考虑不同社会类型中「可能疫苗损害」感知风险的社会正常性及信任与不信任并存模式。
研究设计与样本
- 使用2019年3月访谈的Eurobarometer 91.2调查,样本为欧盟27国及英国统计代表性人群。
- 通过探索性聚类分析识别疫苗有效性、安全性和有用性方面的信念配置。
主要发现
- 约十分之一欧盟27国及英国人群认为疫苗未严格检测即获批。
- 约三分之一认为疫苗可过载或削弱免疫系统,并可导致其所预防的疾病。
- 近半数认为疫苗可致严重副作用。
- 识别出犹豫型(约11%)、自信型(约59%)和权衡型(约29%)三种信念配置。
- 自信型与权衡型接种史相似,提示信念之外其他因素对接种行为有显著作用。
临床怎么用
- 沟通策略应针对不同信念类型(犹豫型、自信型、权衡型)设计差异化信息。
- 需关注权衡型人群对「可能疫苗损害」的感知风险,并处理信任与不信任并存模式。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Despite lacking scientific support, vaccine hesitancy is widespread. While serious vaccine damage as a scientific fact is real yet statistically highly uncommon, emerging social and technological forces have amplified perceptions of risk for "probable vaccine damage", making it a widely shared intersubjective reality. METHODS: Using the Eurobarometer 91.2 survey on a statistically representative EU27-UK sample interviewed in March 2019, we documented perceptions of vaccine risks and identified three belief configurations regarding vaccine effectiveness, safety, and usefulness, through exploratory cluster analysis. RESULTS: The public beliefs in significant vaccine risks are frequent. Approximatively one-tenth of the EU27-UK population consider that vaccines are not rigorously tested before authorization, one-third believe that vaccines can overload or weaken the immune system and that they can cause the disease against which they protect, and almost one-half believe that vaccines can cause serious side effects. We identified three belief configurations: hesitant, confident, and trade-off clusters. The hesitant type (approx. 11% of EU27-UK respondents) is defined by the perception that vaccines are rather ineffective, affected by risks of probable vaccine damage, not well-tested, and useless; the confident type (approx. 59%) is defined by beliefs that vaccines are effective, safe, well-tested, and useful; and the trade-off type (approx. 29%) combines beliefs that vaccines are effective, well-tested and useful, with perceptions of probable vaccine damage. The vaccine-confident and the trade-off types have similar vaccination histories, indicating the significant role of other factors besides beliefs in inducing behavior. CONCLUSIONS: The high proportion of varying public beliefs in significant vaccine risks and the presence of a trade-off type of vaccination assessment indicate the social normality of beliefs in probable vaccine damage. Communication campaigns should take into account the social normality of the perceived risk of "probable vaccine damage" across various social types, and patterns of concomitant trust and mistrust in vaccination.
引用
- Vulpe SN, Rughiniş C. Social amplification of risk and "probable vaccine damage": A typology of vaccination beliefs in 28 European countries. Vaccine. 2021. PMID: 33573865. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2021.01.063
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。