多价与二价疫苗接种策略控制绵羊毒力型腐蹄病的比较
本研究在感染多个Dichelobacter nodosus血清群的绵羊群中比较了多价与二价疫苗接种策略。第一阶段免疫原性试验比较了四种含六或九种血清群的多价重组菌毛疫苗与商业二价疫苗,发现两种多价疫苗抗体反应显著更高,但血清群数量无显著影响;两月间隔足以避免抗原竞争。第二阶段田间试验比较最具免疫原性的九价疫苗与序贯二价疫苗及每月足浴,多价疫苗抗体滴度较低且持续时间较短,保护期可能短于二价疫苗。
要点
- 多价疫苗中血清群数量(六或九种)对免疫原性无显著影响。
- 两月间隔序贯接种二价疫苗足以避免抗原竞争。
- 九价疫苗抗体滴度较低且不持久,保护期可能短于二价疫苗。
核心结论
- 多价疫苗的免疫原性因疫苗配方而异,但包含的血清群数量无显著影响。
- 多价疫苗诱导的抗体滴度较低且持续时间较短,保护期可能短于二价疫苗。
研究设计与样本
- 第一阶段免疫原性试验比较四种多价重组菌毛疫苗(含六或九种血清群)与商业二价疫苗。
- 第二阶段田间试验在四个商业美利奴羊群中比较九价疫苗与序贯二价疫苗及每月足浴。
主要发现
- 两种多价疫苗刺激的抗体反应显著高于另外两种多价疫苗。
- 多价疫苗中血清群数量对免疫原性无显著影响。
- 序贯二价疫苗间两月间隔足以避免抗原竞争。
- 九价疫苗刺激的抗体滴度较低且较不持久。
临床怎么用
- 选择疫苗接种策略时需权衡多价疫苗的便利性与二价疫苗可能更长的保护期。
- 序贯二价疫苗接种可采用两月间隔以避免抗原竞争。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Virulent footrot is a significant economic and animal welfare concern. The disease can be treated, controlled, and eliminated with vaccine, but selecting the appropriate vaccination strategy can be challenging. There are two main strategies: outbreak (serogroup)-specific univalent or bivalent vaccination, or use of a multivalent vaccine containing up to nine of the most common serogroups. The objective of this study was to compare these approaches in sheep flocks infected with multiple Dichelobacter nodosus serogroups. In the first phase, we undertook an immunogenicity trial in which we compared four pre-commercial multivalent recombinant fimbrial vaccines containing six (A, B, C, G, H, I) or nine (A, B, C, D, E, F, G, H, I) serogroups, and compared them to commercial bivalent vaccines. Two multivalent vaccines stimulated significantly higher antibody responses than two other multivalent vaccines but the number of serogroups included in the multivalent vaccine formulations did not have a significant effect. In the first phase, we also compared inter-vaccination intervals of two- and three-months between sequential bivalent vaccines, and found that a two-month interval was sufficient to avoid antigenic competition. In the second phase, the most immunogenic multivalent vaccine (nine serogroups) was compared to sequential bivalent vaccines and monthly foot-bathing in a field trial in four commercial Merino flocks. The duration of protection afforded by the multivalent vaccine was likely to be less than that of the bivalent vaccines, as the antibody titres stimulated were lower and less persistent.
引用
- McPherson AS, Whittington RJ, Hall E, et al. A comparison of multivalent and bivalent vaccination strategies for the control of virulent ovine footrot. Vaccine. 2021. PMID: 33622590. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2021.02.011
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。