满洲鼠疫与COVID-19:中国、美国与「病夫」标签的历史对照
本文通过历史比较,探讨1911年中国东北肺鼠疫与当前COVID-19疫情的相似之处。1911年肺鼠疫在满洲导致逾6万人死亡,此后中国彻底改革公共卫生体系以消除「病夫」污名。文章指出,由于美国应对COVID-19疫情不力,当今中国观察者称美国为「西方病夫」,反映疫病控制与国际地位持续关联,瘟疫既带来悲剧也带来变革机遇。
要点
- 1911年满洲肺鼠疫死亡逾6万人,推动中国公共卫生体系改革。
- 「病夫」标签曾指中国,现被部分中国观察者用于形容美国。
- 疫病控制与国际地位持续关联,瘟疫也带来变革机遇。
核心结论
- 「病夫」一词的历史意义及其当前可能与美国关联,凸显疫病控制与国际地位在变化世界中的持续联系。
- 历史比较揭示瘟疫不仅带来悲剧,也带来变革机遇。
研究设计与样本
- 历史比较分析文章,比较1911年中国满洲肺鼠疫与当前COVID-19疫情。
主要发现
- 1911年满洲肺鼠疫导致逾6万人死亡。
- 20世纪初中国被标签为「远东病夫」,背负鸦片成瘾、传染病和无效政府负担。
- 1911年鼠疫后,革命后的中国彻底重构公共卫生 approach 以消除「病夫」污名。
- 当今中国观察者因美国应对COVID疫情不力称美国为「西方病夫」,背负阿片成瘾、传染病和无效政府负担。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
In this article, I explore the historical resonances between China's 1911 pneumonic plague and our current situation with COVID-19. At the turn of the 20th century, China was labeled "the Sick Man of the Far East": a once-powerful country that had become burdened by opium addiction, infectious disease, and an ineffective government. In 1911, this weakened China faced an outbreak of pneumonic plague in Manchuria that killed more than 60 000 people. After the 1911 plague, a revolutionized China radically restructured its approach to public health to eliminate the stigma of being "the Sick Man." Ironically, given the US mishandling of the COVID pandemic, observers in today's China are now calling the United States "the Sick Man of the West": a country burdened by opioid addiction, infectious disease, and an ineffective government. The historical significance of the phrase "Sick Man"-and its potential to now be associated with the United States-highlights the continued links between epidemic control and international status in a changing world. This historical comparison also reveals that plagues bring not only tragedy but also the opportunity for change.
引用
- Rogaski R. The Manchurian Plague and COVID-19: China, the United States, and the "Sick Man," Then and Now. Am J Public Health. 2021. PMID: 33476233. doi:10.2105/AJPH.2020.305960
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。