比较吸烟减少与改善早年社会条件:英国队列模拟研究
结果显示,改善早年社会条件所降低的死亡率与减少吸烟相近,提示针对早年社会特征的干预具有潜在价值。
要点
- 改善早年社会条件与减少吸烟对降低死亡率的效果相近。
- 女性减少ACE与改善教育相对死亡率变化为-7.2%,减少吸烟为-7.0%。
- 男性对应变化分别为-9.9%与-12.3%。
核心结论
- 针对ACE和教育等早年社会特征的干预可能具有与公认的吸烟干预相当的健康收益。
研究设计与样本
- 采用潜在结局方法与g计算模拟反事实场景,分别对男女进行估计。
主要发现
- 女性减少ACE与改善教育的相对死亡率变化为-7.2%[95%CI(-12.2%至1.2%)],减少吸烟为-7.0%[95%CI(-13.1%至+1.2%)]。
- 男性减少ACE与改善教育的相对死亡率变化为-9.9%[95%CI(-15.6%至-6.2%)],减少吸烟为-12.3%[95%CI(-17.0%至-5.9%)]。
临床怎么用
- 在评估干预优先级时,可考虑将改善早年社会条件(如减少ACE、提高教育)与控烟干预并列。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Health care evaluation models can be useful to assign different levels of priority to interventions or policies targeting different age groups or different determinants of health. We aimed to assess early mortality in counterfactual scenarios implying reduced adverse childhood experience (ACE) and/or improved educational attainment (childhood and early life characteristics), compared with a counterfactual scenario implying reduced smoking in adulthood. METHODS: We used data from the 1958 National Child Development Study British birth cohort, which initially included 18 558 subjects. Applying a potential outcome approach, scenarios were simulated to estimate the expected mortality between ages 16 and 55 under a counterfactual decrease by half of the observed level of exposure to (i) ACE, (ii) low educational attainment (at age 22), (iii) ACE and low educational attainment (a combined exposure) and (iv) smoking at age 33. Estimations were obtained using g-computation, separately for men and women. Analyses were further stratified according to the parental level of education, to assess social inequalities. RESULTS: The study population included 12 164 members. The estimated decrease in mortality in the counterfactual scenarios with reduced ACE and improved educational attainment was close to the decreased mortality in the counterfactual scenario with reduced smoking, showing a relative difference in mortality of respectively -7.2% [95% CI (confidence interval) = (-12.2% to 1.2%)] versus -7.0% (-13.1% to +1.2%) for women, and -9.9% (-15.6% to -6.2%) versus -12.3% (-17.0% to -5.9%) for men. CONCLUSIONS: Our results highlight the potential value of targeting early social characteristics such as ACE and education, compared with well-recognized interventions on smoking.
引用
- Lepage B, Colineaux H, Kelly-Irving M, et al. Comparison of smoking reduction with improvement of social conditions in early life: simulation in a British cohort. Int J Epidemiol. 2021. PMID: 33349858. doi:10.1093/ije/dyaa244
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。