文献速递免疫规划卫生政策与健康促进

医生关于HPV疫苗决策过程的定性研究

Physicians' decision processes about the HPV vaccine: A qualitative study.
PubMed 文献 · Vaccine · 2020-12-13

本研究通过定性访谈法国全科医生、妇科医生和儿科医生,探讨其推荐HPV疫苗的决策过程。研究发现医生对疫苗接种体系利益相关者的信任影响其判断,并识别出五种医生类型,儿科医生在教育者和坚定接种者类型中占比更高。

要点

  • 医生对HPV疫苗的态度受其对接种体系利益相关者信任度的影响。
  • 医生与患者互动方式分为告知说服、适应患者意见和拒绝妥协三类。
  • 识别出五种医生类型:异议者、犹豫者、放任者、教育者和坚定接种者。

核心结论

  • 医生对HPV疫苗的推荐决策受其对疫苗接种策略设计和实施中利益相关者信任度的影响。
  • 医生在决策上与非专业人士无实质差异,但受其专业风格和职业理念的强烈影响。

研究设计与样本

  • 对法国全科医生、妇科医生和儿科医生进行定性访谈。
  • 首先从全国医疗专业人员注册库中随机选取医生,再通过滚雪球法构建便利样本。
  • 采用主题分析法对访谈进行编码,编码框架结合归纳和演绎方式。

主要发现

  • 三分之二的参与者(19/28)对HPV疫苗接种持赞成态度,4人反对,其余对推荐犹豫。
  • 大多数参与者提到信任疫苗接种体系中的利益相关者;信任度越低,对疫苗的批评越多,越重视患者意见。
  • 识别出三种与患者互动方式:告知并说服、适应患者意见、拒绝在接种上妥协。
  • 交叉主题后发现五种医生类型:异议者、犹豫者、放任者、教育者和坚定接种者。
  • 儿科医生在后两种类型(教育者和坚定接种者)中占比过高。

临床怎么用

  • 了解医生对HPV疫苗的决策类型有助于设计针对性培训或沟通策略,以提升推荐一致性。
  • 对于犹豫或异议的医生,可能需要干预以增强其对疫苗接种体系的信任。

局限性

  • 研究采用便利样本和滚雪球法,可能存在选择偏倚。
  • 定性研究结果不能推广到所有医生群体。
  • 样本仅来自法国,背景特定。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: The contemporary crisis of trust in vaccines has severely impaired acceptance of the HPV vaccine, especially in France, where its uptake culminated at 23.7% in 2018 (complete course at age 16). Physicians' recommendations strongly influence its acceptance/refusal. Our study sought to understand the decision processes leading physicians to recommend this vaccine (or not). METHODS: Qualitative interviews of French physicians (general practitioners, gynecologists, and pediatricians). We first randomly selected doctors in a national register of medical professionals and then resorted to snowballing to build a convenience sample. We coded the interviews in a thematic analysis built both inductively and deductively from our research questions and data. RESULTS: Two thirds of the participants (19/28) were favorable to HPV vaccination, some (4) opposed it, while the others were hesitant about recommending it. In explaining their opinions, most participants mentioned that they trusted the stakeholders within the vaccination system: the less trust they had, the more critical they were of the vaccine and the more importance they attributed to patients' opinions. We identified three different ways they interacted with patients on this topic: informing and convincing; adapting to patients' opinions; refusing compromise about vaccination. Crossing these various themes, we found 5 types of physicians: dissidents (mistrustful of the healthcare system and HPV vaccine), hesitant (finding it difficult to make up their minds about this vaccination), laissez-faire (letting patients decide by themselves, but very favorable to HPV vaccination), educator (very favorable), and uncompromising vaccinators (refusing debate). Pediatricians were overrepresented among the latter two types. CONCLUSIONS: Physicians' judgment was influenced by their trust in the stakeholders involved in designing and implementing the HPV vaccination strategy. In this sense, doctors did not differ substantially from laypeople. They were, nonetheless, strongly influenced by their professional style and ethos.

来源:Vaccine,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Bouchez M, Ward JK, Bocquier A, et al. Physicians' decision processes about the HPV vaccine: A qualitative study. Vaccine. 2020. PMID: 33328141. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2020.12.019

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。