文献速递传染病防控与疫情报告卫生政策与健康促进

国际输入病例对COVID-19内部传播影响的数学建模研究

Effect of internationally imported cases on internal spread of COVID-19: a mathematical modelling study.
PubMed 文献 · Lancet Public Health · 2020-12-07

该研究通过数学建模框架,估算2020年5月和9月各国国际旅行输入的COVID-19病例占内部传播病例的比例。结果显示,2020年5月许多国家输入病例占比较高,而9月大多数国家输入病例占比不超过10%,部分国家甚至低于1%。结论认为旅行限制仅在低发病率且旅客量大的国家或疫情接近指数增长临界点时才有显著效果。

要点

  • 2020年5月假设无旅行限制时,136国中102国输入病例占新增病例超10%。
  • 2020年9月假设无旅行限制时,162国中106国输入病例占比不超过10%。
  • 44国中22国疫情增长率远离指数增长临界点,旅行限制获益最小。

核心结论

  • 国际输入病例在疫情早期可能占比较高,但后期在许多国家贡献较小。
  • 严格旅行限制仅在低发病率且旅客量大或疫情接近指数增长临界点的国家有显著影响。
  • 各国应结合本地发病率、疫情增长和旅行量决定是否实施旅行限制。

研究设计与样本

  • 数学建模研究,估算2020年5月和9月各国平均每日输入病例与内部传播病例的比例。
  • 使用调整报告不足和无症状感染的模型框架估计COVID-19患病率和发病率。
  • 考虑两种旅行情景:2019年旅行量上限和2020年预期旅行量下限。

主要发现

  • 2020年5月无旅行限制时,136国中102国(95%可信区间63-129)输入病例占总数超10%。
  • 2020年5月按2020年旅行量估计,74国(33-114)输入病例占比超10%。
  • 2020年9月无旅行限制时,162国中106国(50-140)输入病例占比不超过10%,21国(4-71)低于1%。
  • 2020年9月按2020年旅行量估计,125国(65-162)输入病例占比不超过10%,44国(8-97)低于1%。
  • 44国中22国(2-61)疫情增长率远离指数增长临界点,最不可能从旅行限制中获益。

关键数值与推荐

  • 2020年5月无旅行限制时,102/136国输入病例占比>10%(95%可信区间63-129)。
  • 2020年5月按2020年旅行量估计,74国输入病例占比>10%(33-114)。
  • 2020年9月无旅行限制时,106/162国输入病例占比≤10%(50-140),21国<1%(4-71)。
  • 2020年9月按2020年旅行量估计,125国输入病例占比≤10%(65-162),44国<1%(8-97)。
  • 44国中22国疫情增长率远离指数增长临界点(2-61)。

临床怎么用

  • 各国在实施国际旅行限制前应评估本地COVID-19发病率、疫情增长趋势和旅行量。
  • 对于发病率低且旅客量大的国家,旅行限制可能对疫情控制有较大贡献。
  • 对于疫情增长率远离指数增长临界点的国家,旅行限制对本地疫情动态影响可能较小。

局限性

  • 模型依赖报告病例调整估计,可能存在不确定性。
  • 旅行量情景基于2019年数据和2020年预期减少的假设。
  • 结果解释需结合当地疫情增长率的背景。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Countries have restricted international arrivals to delay the spread of severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2). These measures carry a high economic and social cost, and might have little effect on COVID-19 epidemics if there are many more cases resulting from local transmission compared with imported cases. Our study aims to investigate the extent to which imported cases contribute to local transmission under different epidemic conditions. METHODS: To inform decisions about international travel restrictions, we calculated the ratio of expected COVID-19 cases from international travel (assuming no travel restrictions) to expected cases arising from internal spread, expressed as a proportion, on an average day in May and September, 2020, in each country. COVID-19 prevalence and incidence were estimated using a modelling framework that adjusts reported cases for under-ascertainment and asymptomatic infections. We considered different travel scenarios for May and September, 2020: an upper bound with estimated travel volumes at the same levels as May and September, 2019, and a lower bound with estimated travel volumes adjusted downwards according to expected reductions in May and September, 2020. Results were interpreted in the context of local epidemic growth rates. FINDINGS: In May, 2020, imported cases are likely to have accounted for a high proportion of total incidence in many countries, contributing more than 10% of total incidence in 102 (95% credible interval 63-129) of 136 countries when assuming no reduction in travel volumes (ie, with 2019 travel volumes) and in 74 countries (33-114) when assuming estimated 2020 travel volumes. Imported cases in September, 2020, would have accounted for no more than 10% of total incidence in 106 (50-140) of 162 countries and less than 1% in 21 countries (4-71) when assuming no reductions in travel volumes. With estimated 2020 travel volumes, imported cases in September, 2020, accounted for no more than 10% of total incidence in 125 countries (65-162) and less than 1% in 44 countries (8-97). Of these 44 countries, 22 (2-61) had epidemic growth rates far from the tipping point of exponential growth, making them the least likely to benefit from travel restrictions. INTERPRETATION: Countries can expect travellers infected with SARS-CoV-2 to arrive in the absence of travel restrictions. Although such restrictions probably contribute to epidemic control in many countries, in others, imported cases are likely to contribute little to local COVID-19 epidemics. Stringent travel restrictions might have little impact on epidemic dynamics except in countries with low COVID-19 incidence and large numbers of arrivals from other countries, or where epidemics are close to tipping points for exponential growth. Countries should consider local COVID-19 incidence, local epidemic growth, and travel volumes before implementing such restrictions. FUNDING: Wellcome Trust, UK Foreign, Commonwealth & Development Office, European Commission, National Institute for Health Research, Medical Research Council, and Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation.

来源:Lancet Public Health,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Russell TW, Wu JT, Clifford S, et al. Effect of internationally imported cases on internal spread of COVID-19: a mathematical modelling study. Lancet Public Health. 2020. PMID: 33301722. doi:10.1016/S2468-2667(20)30263-2

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。