也门复杂人道主义紧急情况下医疗可及性的地理空间分析
该研究利用地理空间分析估计也门医疗可及性,整合卫生设施评估、人口分布建模和道路网络数据构建出行时间模型。结果显示2018年约8·8百万(30·6%)人口到最近可运作公立初级卫生保健设施出行时间超过30分钟,超12·1百万(42·4%)人口到最近可运作公立医院超过1小时,近40%人口到综合急诊产科和手术护理超过2小时。研究按超出可接受出行时间的人口数对地区排序,发现一线地区可及性最差。
要点
- 2018年也门约30·6%人口到最近可运作公立初级卫生保健设施出行时间超过30分钟。
- 约42·4%人口到最近可运作公立医院出行时间超过1小时。
- 近40%人口到综合急诊产科和手术护理出行时间超过2小时。
核心结论
- 也门医疗可及性存在显著地区差异,许多一线地区可及性最差。
- 地理空间技术可填补数据缺口并为卫生规划提供依据。
研究设计与样本
- 描述性应用地理空间分析,基于WHO和也门卫生部Health Resources and Services Availability Monitoring System评估数据。
- 使用高分辨率卫星影像、联合国人口估计和普查数据建模人口空间分布。
- 从OpenStreetMap和卫星数据构建道路网络网格,并利用联合国也门后勤集群数据等修正冲突线和道路可达性。
- 建立地理空间网络模型推算也门人到最近卫生设施的出行时间。
主要发现
- 2018年也门总人口估计为28·7百万,其中近8·8百万(30·6%)到最近完全或部分运作的公立初级卫生保健设施出行时间超过30分钟(假设可获取机动交通工具)。
- 超过12·1百万(42·4%)也门人到最近完全或部分运作的公立医院出行时间超过1小时(假设可获取机动交通工具)。
- 近40%人口到综合急诊产科和手术护理出行时间超过2小时。
- 可及性因地区和卫生服务类型差异很大,许多一线地区可及性最差。
- 按超出可接受出行时间的人口数对地区进行了识别和排序。
临床怎么用
- 可利用地理空间分析识别和优先排序需要援助的人群,指导人道主义和发展响应。
- 研究结果可用于实时操作中定位服务不足地区并评估干预影响。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: In conflict settings, data to guide humanitarian and development responses are often scarce. Although geospatial analyses have been used to estimate health-care access in many countries, such techniques have not been widely applied to inform real-time operations in protracted health emergencies. Doing so could provide a more robust approach for identifying and prioritising populations in need, targeting assistance, and assessing impact. We aimed to use geospatial analyses to overcome such data gaps in Yemen, the site of one of the world's worst ongoing humanitarian crises. METHODS: We derived geospatial coordinates, functionality, and service availability data for Yemen health facilities from the Health Resources and Services Availability Monitoring System assessment done by WHO and the Yemen Ministry of Public Health and Population. We modelled population spatial distribution using high-resolution satellite imagery, UN population estimates, and census data. A road network grid was built from OpenStreetMap and satellite data and modified using UN Yemen Logistics Cluster data and other datasets to account for lines of conflict and road accessibility. Using this information, we created a geospatial network model to deduce the travel time of Yemeni people to their nearest health-care facilities. FINDINGS: In 2018, we estimated that nearly 8·8 million (30·6%) of the total estimated Yemeni population of 28·7 million people lived more than 30-min travel time from the nearest fully or partially functional public primary health-care facility, and more than 12·1 million (42·4%) Yemeni people lived more than 1 h from the nearest fully or partially functional public hospital, assuming access to motorised transport. We found that access varied widely by district and type of health service, with almost 40% of the population living more than 2 h from comprehensive emergency obstetric and surgical care. We identified and ranked districts according to the number of people living beyond acceptable travel times to facilities and services. We found substantial variability in access and that many front-line districts were among those with the poorest access. INTERPRETATION: These findings provide the most comprehensive estimates of geographical access to health care in Yemen since the outbreak of the current conflict, and they provide proof of concept for how geospatial techniques can be used to address data gaps and rigorously inform health programming. Such information is of crucial importance for humanitarian and development organisations seeking to improve effectiveness and accountability. FUNDING: Global Financing Facility for Women, Children, and Adolescents Trust Fund; Development and Data Science grant; and the Yemen Emergency Health and Nutrition Project, a partnership between the World Bank, UNICEF, and WHO.
引用
- Garber K, Fox C, Abdalla M, et al. Estimating access to health care in Yemen, a complex humanitarian emergency setting: a descriptive applied geospatial analysis. Lancet Glob Health. 2020. PMID: 33069304. doi:10.1016/S2214-109X(20)30359-4
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。