文献速递免疫规划卫生政策与健康促进

国家免疫技术咨询组在加强卫生系统治理中的作用:阿根廷、约旦和南非的经验

The role of National Immunization Technical Advisory Groups (NITAG) in strengthening health system governance: Lessons from three middle-income countries-Argentina, Jordan, and South Africa (2017-2018).
PubMed 文献 · Vaccine · 2020-09-16

该研究于2017-2018年在阿根廷、约旦和南非三个中等收入国家开展定性回顾性研究,通过文献回顾和53次关键知情人访谈,评估国家免疫技术咨询组(NITAG)对卫生治理的贡献。研究发现NITAG作为顾问推动循证决策文化,加强了治理,但透明度、参与度和问责制实践因国家而异,卫生部支持和利益冲突管理存在显著问题。

要点

  • NITAG作为顾问推动循证决策文化,在加强治理中发挥关键作用。
  • 会议闭门举行、参与受限,仅阿根廷公开建议,透明度实践不一。
  • NITAG自主运作但缺乏监测监督,利益冲突声明与文档管理存在问题。

核心结论

  • 系统实施治理方法可改善流程、更好定制政策和实施。
  • NITAG在这些国家的长期存续和韧性显示其在加强治理中发挥重要作用。

研究设计与样本

  • 2017-2018年开展两步定性回顾性研究。
  • 选择约旦、阿根廷和南非因政府资助NITAG、地理多样性和有NITAG支持的疫苗引入。
  • 通过文献回顾和面对面关键知情人访谈收集数据,共53次访谈(阿根廷22、南非20、约旦11)。
  • 应用欧洲卫生系统与政策观察站框架评估治理,关注透明度、问责制、参与、诚信和政策能力(TAPIC)。

主要发现

  • NITAG作为顾问推动循证政策文化,加强了治理但实践因国家而异。
  • 会议闭门举行,参与限于成员,仅阿根廷公开会议议程和建议。
  • 为增加参与、政策能力和透明度,各国考虑增加通信、倡导和经济学专家,阿根廷和南非考虑纳入社区成员。
  • NITAG自主运作,无内部或外部监测监督,会议记录用于审查诚信、遵守职权范围、标准操作程序和利益冲突。
  • NITAG大多遵守任务授权,显著问题涉及卫生部支持水平及利益冲突声明和文档监督。

临床怎么用

  • 系统实施治理方法可改善NITAG流程,更好定制政策和实施。
  • NITAG经验可用于促进国家驱动的循证决策。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

INTRODUCTION: Toward the Global Vaccine Action Plan 2020 goal, almost 90% of countries have established a National Immunization Technical Advisory Group (NITAG). However, little is known about NITAG's contributions to governance. METHODS: In 2017-2018, a two-step, qualitative retrospective study was conducted. Jordan (JO), Argentina (AR), and South Africa (SA) were selected owing to government-financed NITAGs from middle-income countries (MICs), geographic diversity, and a vaccine introduction with NITAG support. Country case studies were developed, collecting data through desk review and face-to-face key informant interviews (KIIs) from Ministry of Health (MoH) and NITAG. Case studies were analyzed together, to assess governance applying the European Observatory on Health Systems and Policies framework focusing on transparency, accountability, participation, integrity, and policy capacity (TAPIC). RESULTS: Document review and 53 KII (22 AR, 20 SA, 11 JO) showed NITAGs played a pivotal role as advisors promoting a culture of evidence-informed policies. NITAGs strengthened governance, although practices varied among countries. Meetings were conducted behind-closed-doors, participation restricted to members, only in one country agendas, and recommendations were public (AR). To increase participation, policy capacity, and transparency, countries considered adding experts in communications, advocacy, and economics. AR and SA contemplated including community members. NITAGs functioned autonomously from the government, with no established internal or external monitoring or supervision. NITAG meeting minutes allowed the review of integrity, adherence to terms of reference, standard operating procedures, and conflict of interest (CoI). For the most part, NITAGs abided by their mandates. Significant issues were related to the level of MoH support and oversight of CoI declaration and documentation. CONCLUSIONS: Systematically implementing governance approaches could improve processes, better tailor policies, and implementation. The long-term survival and resilience of NITAGs in these countries showed they play a significant role in strengthening governance. Lessons learned could be useful to those promoting country-driven evidence-informed decision-making.

来源:Vaccine,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Panero MS, Khuri-Bulos N, Biscayart C, et al. The role of National Immunization Technical Advisory Groups (NITAG) in strengthening health system governance: Lessons from three middle-income countries-Argentina, Jordan, and South Africa (2017-2018). Vaccine. 2020. PMID: 32950303. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2020.08.069

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。