香港护理人员流感疫苗犹豫的连续谱研究
该研究在香港2017/18冬季流感季后以在线问卷开展横断面调查,采用多重对应分析与K-means聚类将护士按疫苗犹豫程度分组,并用广义有序logistic回归分析相关因素。结果显示护士总体接种覆盖率为44%,共区分出5个犹豫程度不同的亚组,超过半数护士处于中度或更高犹豫水平。
要点
- 香港护士2017/18季流感疫苗接种覆盖率为44%。
- 聚类识别出5个疫苗犹豫亚组,中度及以上犹豫者超过半数。
- 完成至少3年注册前专业培训、多数家庭成员接种及学生时期接种史与较低犹豫相关。
核心结论
- 香港护士中超过半数处于中度或更高水平的流感疫苗犹豫,针对各亚组特征的定制化干预可作为提升接种率的重要策略。
研究设计与样本
- 横断面研究,于2017/18冬季流感季后对香港护士开展在线问卷调查。
- 采用多重对应分析与K-means聚类划分疫苗犹豫连续谱亚组,并以广义有序logistic回归分析社会人口学、职业与个人相关因素。
主要发现
- 护士2017/18流感季总体接种覆盖率为44%。
- 非常高度犹豫至完全拒绝组n=56(7%),以直接拒绝接种为特征。
- 高度犹豫组n=171(23%),以倾向跳接种及对疫苗安全性持怀疑为特征。
- 中度犹豫组n=273(36%),对接种不确定、不信任政府疫苗推荐并优先关注疫苗可负担性。
- 低度犹豫组n=95(13%)为谨慎接受接种;无至极低犹豫组n=158(21%)疫苗信心强且接种依从性与接种可及性便利高度相关。
临床怎么用
- 可依据犹豫连续谱各亚组特征设计针对性干预,而非统一策略,以提升护士流感疫苗接种率。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: Influenza vaccine hesitancy among healthcare workers poses challenges to the achievement of herd immunity and causes infection risks to vulnerable patients. This study aimed to quantify the extent of influenza vaccine hesitancy among nurses in Hong Kong, to delineate its pattern, and to explore its socio-demographic, professional and personal correlates. METHOD: Nurses in Hong Kong were recruited in a cross-sectional study involving the administration of an online questionnaire survey after the 2017/18 winter influenza season. Respondents' influenza vaccination behaviours, attitudes and psychological antecedents were assessed, followed by their delineation into subgroups along the hesitancy continuum through a combination of multiple correspondence analysis and K-means cluster analysis. Socio-demographic, professional and personal correlations of subgrouping were investigated using generalised ordered logistic regression. RESULTS: The overall vaccination coverage of nurses for the 2017/18 influenza season was 44%. Five clusters were differentiated by the level of influenza vaccine hesitancy: "Very high hesitancy-to-complete refusal" (n = 56; 7%) characterised by outright refusal of vaccination; "High hesitancy" (n = 171; 23%) distinguished by tendency of skipping vaccination and scepticism about safety of vaccine; "Moderate hesitancy" (n = 273; 36%) with uncertainties towards vaccination, mistrust of the government's vaccine recommendations and priority concern on affordability of vaccine; "Low hesitancy" (n = 95; 13%) with cautious acceptance towards vaccination and "No-to-minimal hesitancy" (n = 158; 21%) with strong vaccine confidence and compliance greatly linked to convenience of vaccine access. Nurses having completed at least 3 years' pre-registration professional training, having most family members vaccinated against influenza, and with influenza vaccination history during studentship were less vaccine hesitant. CONCLUSION: With more than half of the nurses in Hong Kong having moderate or higher level of influenza vaccine hesitancy, interventions customised to the needs of nurses as reflected from the characteristics of clusters along the vaccine hesitancy continuum could form an important strategy for improving vaccination uptake.
引用
- Lau LHW, Lee SS, Wong NS, et al. The continuum of influenza vaccine hesitancy among nursing professionals in Hong Kong. Vaccine. 2020. PMID: 32891475. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2020.08.038
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。