比利时与越南婴儿抗体滴度动力学差异的建模研究
本研究利用越南和比利时两项母婴免疫双生子研究的血清学数据,采用非线性混合效应模型比较婴儿在母体抗体存在下疫苗接种前后的抗PT和抗Prn抗体动力学。结果显示越南婴儿出生时抗PT和抗Prn抗体滴度显著低于比利时婴儿,可能与孕妇使用不同疫苗品牌及疫苗接种史差异有关。分析提示初次免疫期间存在Blunting效应,抗PT的Blunting效应之后消失,而抗Prn的Blunting效应持续至加强免疫后可能消失。
要点
- 越南婴儿出生时抗PT和抗Prn抗体滴度显著低于比利时婴儿
- 母体抗体Blunting效应在初次免疫期间存在,抗PT后消失,抗Prn持续至加强免疫后可能消失
- 两国孕妇使用不同Tdap疫苗品牌及接种史差异可能解释抗体滴度差异
核心结论
- 越南婴儿出生时抗PT和抗Prn抗体滴度显著低于比利时婴儿,可能与孕妇疫苗品牌和接种史差异有关。
- 初次免疫期间存在Blunting效应,抗PT的Blunting效应之后消失,抗Prn的Blunting效应持续至加强免疫后可能消失。
研究设计与样本
- 利用越南和比利时两项母婴免疫双生子研究的血清学数据,在单一实验室检测。
- 采用非线性混合效应模型(NLMMs)建模抗PT和抗Prn抗体动态。
- 孕妇接种Tdap疫苗(比利时Boostrix®,越南Adacel®),儿童在初次和加强接种前后随访。
主要发现
- 越南婴儿出生时抗PT和抗Prn抗体滴度显著低于比利时婴儿(接种疫苗母亲组)。
- 比利时接种疫苗母亲组婴儿脐带抗体滴度也高于越南对照母亲组婴儿,但差异不显著。
- 初次免疫期间存在Blunting效应,抗PT的Blunting效应之后消失,抗Prn的Blunting效应持续至加强免疫后可能消失。
临床怎么用
- 各国在推荐母体免疫时应了解区域情况,考虑疫苗品牌和接种史对婴儿抗体动力学的影响。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Serological results obtained in a single laboratory from twin-studies on maternal immunisation, in Vietnam and Belgium offer the opportunity to compare antibody kinetics in infants before and after infant vaccination in the presence of vaccine-induced maternal antibodies. Nonlinear mixed-effects models (NLMMs) making use of a hypothesised dynamic evolution that captures the change in antibody titres over time, were employed to model anti-PT and anti-Prn antibody dynamics. Our proposed modelling approach provided useful insight into understanding the differences in the infants' antibody kinetics in both countries since NLMMs offer the possibility of pooling all data in one analysis and incorporate relevant covariates of interest. In both controlled cohort studies, pregnant women were vaccinated with a tetanus, diphtheria, acellular pertussis (Tdap) vaccine (Boostrix®, Belgium; Adacel®, Vietnam), and children were followed before and after primary vaccination, and before and after booster vaccination (Infanrix hexa®). From our models, both anti-PRN and anti-PT antibody titres at birth of Vietnamese infants were significantly lower than those of Belgian infants born to vaccinated women groups. Even though the antibody titres in the cord at birth of Belgian infants were also higher than those of Vietnamese infants born to the control women groups, the difference was not significant. The significant difference between infants born to vaccinated women in the two countries was likely due to the use of different vaccine brands in pregnant women and the different vaccination histories of women in these two countries. Our analyses also suggested that the blunting effect was present during the primary immunisation but went away afterward for anti-PT data. In contrast, for anti-PRN antibodies, the blunting effect persisted after the primary vaccination and possibly went away after the booster dose. Countries should be aware of the regional situation in view of recommending maternal immunization.
引用
- Tran TMP, Maertens K, Hoang HTT, et al. Elucidating the difference in the kinetics of antibody titres of infants in Belgium and Vietnam. Vaccine. 2020. PMID: 32933790. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2020.09.003
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。