瑞典COVID-19医疗需求与死亡率:非药物干预情景对比
该研究用年龄分层SEIR模型模拟瑞典各市不同非药物干预情景下的医疗需求与死亡。中度至强物理距离情景与实际观察至2020年5月底的医疗需求和死亡吻合,ICU需求略超500床;反事实情景ICU需求约为大流行前能力的20倍。
要点
- 中度至强物理距离情景与瑞典至2020年5月底观察数据吻合。
- 该情景ICU需求略超大流行前最大能力500床。
- 反事实情景ICU需求约为大流行前能力的20倍。
核心结论
- 不同非药物干预组合,尤其适度物理距离结合更有效隔离感染者,可降低死亡、医疗需求与费用。
- 低效缓解情景下ICU床位需求会迅速超容量,显示医疗需求与物理距离紧密关联。
研究设计与样本
- 采用年龄分层医疗需求扩展SEIR compartmental模型覆盖瑞典所有市,并用辐射模型描述市际流动。
- 模型以斯德哥尔摩医疗区各市数据校准。
主要发现
- 中度至强物理距离情景较好描述瑞典至2020年5月底观察到的医疗需求与死亡。
- 该情景ICU需求达到略高于500床的大流行前最大能力。
- 反事实情景ICU需求估计约为大流行前ICU能力的20倍。
- 全因超额死亡统计分析提示COVID-19归因死亡数可能增加40%(95%CI 0.24–0.57)。
临床怎么用
- 应维持物理距离水平更长时间以抑制或缓解大流行影响。
- 需将适度物理距离与更有效隔离感染者组合以降低死亡与医疗需求。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: While the COVID-19 outbreak in China now appears suppressed, Europe and the USA have become the epicentres, both reporting many more deaths than China. Responding to the pandemic, Sweden has taken a different approach aiming to mitigate, not suppress, community transmission, by using physical distancing without lockdowns. Here we contrast the consequences of different responses to COVID-19 within Sweden, the resulting demand for care, intensive care, the death tolls and the associated direct healthcare related costs. METHODS: We used an age-stratified health-care demand extended SEIR (susceptible, exposed, infectious, recovered) compartmental model for all municipalities in Sweden, and a radiation model for describing inter-municipality mobility. The model was calibrated against data from municipalities in the Stockholm healthcare region. RESULTS: Our scenario with moderate to strong physical distancing describes well the observed health demand and deaths in Sweden up to the end of May 2020. In this scenario, the intensive care unit (ICU) demand reaches the pre-pandemic maximum capacity just above 500 beds. In the counterfactual scenario, the ICU demand is estimated to reach ∼20 times higher than the pre-pandemic ICU capacity. The different scenarios show quite different death tolls up to 1 September, ranging from 5000 to 41 000, excluding deaths potentially caused by ICU shortage. Additionally, our statistical analysis of all causes excess mortality indicates that the number of deaths attributable to COVID-19 could be increased by 40% (95% confidence interval: 0.24, 0.57). CONCLUSION: The results of this study highlight the impact of different combinations of non-pharmaceutical interventions, especially moderate physical distancing in combination with more effective isolation of infectious individuals, on reducing deaths, health demands and lowering healthcare costs. In less effective mitigation scenarios, the demand on ICU beds would rapidly exceed capacity, showing the tight interconnection between the healthcare demand and physical distancing in the society. These findings have relevance for Swedish policy and response to the COVID-19 pandemic and illustrate the importance of maintaining the level of physical distancing for a longer period beyond the study period to suppress or mitigate the impacts from the pandemic.
引用
- Sjödin H, Johansson AF, Brännström Å, et al. COVID-19 healthcare demand and mortality in Sweden in response to non-pharmaceutical mitigation and suppression scenarios. Int J Epidemiol. 2020. PMID: 32954400. doi:10.1093/ije/dyaa121
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。