法国2005至2014年疟疾死亡负担:捕获-再捕获估算
该研究估算法国本土2005至2014年输入性疟疾相关院内死亡数,将国家疟疾参考中心数据与死亡登记和医院出院数据库匹配,采用对数线性模型捕获-再捕获分析。估计期间疟疾相关死亡205例(95%CI:191-219),年均21例(95%CI:19-22),参考中心监测敏感性仅38%(95%CI:32-44)。
要点
- 法国本土年均疟疾相关死亡约21例(95%CI:19-22)。
- 国家疟疾参考中心死亡监测敏感性为38%(95%CI:32-44)。
- 输入性疟疾死亡漏报显著,跨国比较需按监测完整性加权。
核心结论
- 法国本土2005至2014年估计疟疾相关死亡205例(95%CI:191-219),年均21例(95%CI:19-22)。
- 疟疾死亡记录完整性显著低于病例记录,国家参考中心监测敏感性仅38%(95%CI:32-44)。
研究设计与样本
- 采用对数线性模型的捕获-再捕获方法,并按年龄、性别和死亡地点分层以去除异质性。
主要发现
- 估计研究期间法国本土疟疾相关死亡205例(95%CI:191-219),年均21例(95%CI:19-22)。
- 三个数据来源合计报告161例院内个体疟疾相关死亡,男女比为2.6,中位年龄57岁(范围1至89岁)。
- 国家疟疾参考中心疟疾相关死亡监测敏感性为38%(95%CI:32-44)。
关键数值与推荐
- 输入性疟疾死亡负担估计值:205例(95%CI:191-219),年均21例(95%CI:19-22)。
- 参考中心死亡监测敏感性:38%(95%CI:32-44)。
- 161例院内死亡中男女比2.6,中位年龄57岁(范围1至89岁)。
临床怎么用
- 应加强疟疾死亡报告与多源数据核对,以提高死亡监测完整性。
- 比较各国输入性疟疾发病与死亡时,须使用按监测系统完整性加权的标准指标。
局限性
- 仅纳入法国本土院内死亡,可能低估院外或未入院死亡。
- 捕获-再捕获估计依赖数据源独立性与分层模型假设。
- 死亡记录完整性显著低于病例记录,影响直接比较。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
IntroductionMalaria is a notifiable disease in all European Union and European Economic Area countries except Belgium and France, where only autochthonous malaria is notifiable. Although morbidity caused by malaria has been assessed, little is known about mortality incidence.ObjectiveOur aim was to estimate the number of imported malaria-related deaths in hospital in metropolitan France.MethodsWe matched individual deaths reported between 1 January 2005 and 31 December 2014 to the French National Reference Centre for malaria (FNRCm) with malaria-related deaths from two other sources: the French National Registry on medical causes of death and the French national hospital discharge database. A capture-recapture method with log-linear modelling was used. Age, sex and place of death stratification were applied to remove heterogeneity.ResultsThe estimated malaria-related deaths in metropolitan France during the study period were 205 (95% confidence interval (CI): 191-219). The annual mean number of malaria-related deaths was estimated at 21 (95% CI: 19-22). The FNRCm malaria-related deaths surveillance had a 38% sensitivity (95% CI: 32-44). Among 161 in-hospital individual malaria-related deaths reported from three data sources, the sex ratio (male to female) was 2.6. Median age of the patients was 57 years, ranging from 1 to 89 years.ConclusionThe pertinent finding of this report is that malaria-related death records were significantly less complete [corrected] than case records. Therefore, data comparison of imported malaria morbidity and mortality between countries should imperatively be assessed using standard indicators weighted according to the completeness of health surveillance systems.
引用
- Kendjo E, Thellier M, Noël H, et al. Mortality from malaria in France, 2005 to 2014. Euro Surveill. 2020. PMID: 32914747. doi:10.2807/1560-7917.ES.2020.25.36.1900579
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。