在线风险评估识别医护人员狂犬病暴露的效果评价——犹他州,2019年
2018年犹他州报告1944年以来首例确诊人狂犬病死亡病例,患者曾在三县两州四家医疗机构及急救转运服务接受19天治疗。犹他州卫生部基于免疫实践咨询委员会建议开发标准化在线风险评估调查,并评价其准确性、可接受性和行政负担。在线工具初始识别90名可能暴露的医护人员,其中74名被归类为暴露并全部接受暴露后预防,评估工具阳性预测值为82%;55名受访者中42名(76%)对评估过程满意。
要点
- 在线风险评估工具阳性预测值为82%,可有效识别需暴露后预防的医护人员。
- 74名被归类为暴露的医护人员全部接受暴露后预防。
- 55名受访者中42名(76%)对评估过程满意,焦点小组建议补充狂犬病暴露信息。
核心结论
- 在线风险评估工具在大规模狂犬病暴露事件中能有效识别需暴露后预防的医护人员,阳性预测值为82%。
- 该工具在识别暴露人员方面具有较好准确性,且多数受访者对其可接受性表示满意。
- 评价结果强调清晰沟通策略的重要性,并为CDC改进州和医疗机构资源提供具体反馈。
研究设计与样本
- 对犹他州卫生部基于免疫实践咨询委员会建议开发的标准化在线风险评估调查进行评价。
- 通过回顾工具结果、开展焦点小组讨论和后续调查评估工具的准确性、可接受性和行政义务。
- 评价场景为2018年一例人狂犬病死亡病例,该患者曾在三县两州四家医疗机构及急救转运服务接受19天治疗。
主要发现
- 在线风险评估初始识别90名可能暴露于感染性物质的医护人员,其中74名被归类为暴露。
- 74名被归类为暴露的医护人员在与职业健康人员咨询后全部接受暴露后预防。
- 评估工具的阳性预测值为82%。
- 55名后续调查受访者中42名(76%)报告对评估过程满意。
- 焦点小组参与者建议补充狂犬病暴露相关信息,因许多人不熟悉人传人狂犬病传播。
关键数值与推荐
- 在线风险评估工具阳性预测值为82%。
- 55名后续调查受访者中42名(76%)对评估过程满意。
临床怎么用
- 在大规模狂犬病暴露事件中,可使用基于指南的在线风险评估工具快速识别需暴露后预防的医护人员。
- 应配合清晰沟通策略,向医护人员提供狂犬病暴露及人传人传播相关知识。
- 医疗机构和州卫生部门可参考该工具及反馈优化暴露后评估流程和资源配置。
局限性
- 评价基于单次事件,结果外推需谨慎。
- 焦点小组参与者反映对狂犬病暴露及人传人传播不熟悉,可能影响评估应答质量。
- 后续调查应答率为55名受访者,存在无应答偏倚可能。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
On November 7, 2018, the Utah Department of Health (UDOH) reported the first confirmed human rabies death in the state since 1944 (1). The case occurred in a person who had been treated over a period of 19 days at four health care facilities and an emergency medical transport service across three counties and two states. Human rabies is preventable through preexposure or postexposure vaccination but is invariably fatal upon symptom onset. Timely identification of persons who might have been exposed to rabies virus is therefore crucial to administer postexposure prophylaxis (PEP). Because of the large number of health care workers who had been involved in the patient's care, a standardized online risk assessment survey was developed by UDOH based on Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices recommendations (2). This online tool was evaluated for accuracy, acceptability, and administrative obligation by reviewing the results from the tool and conducting focus group discussions and a follow-up survey. Among 90 health care workers initially identified by the online risk assessment as being potentially exposed to infectious material, 74 were classified as exposed. All 74 health care workers received PEP following consultation with occupational health staff members, indicating a positive predictive value of the assessment tool of 82%. In a follow-up survey, 42 (76%) of the 55 respondents reported that they were satisfied with the assessment process. In focus group discussions, participants suggested that the survey could be improved by providing additional information about rabies exposures because many of them were unfamiliar with human-to-human rabies transmission. This evaluation highlighted the importance of adopting clear communication strategies, demonstrated the benefits of using an online risk assessment during a mass rabies exposure, and provided specific feedback for CDC to improve resources available for states and health care facilities after mass rabies exposures.
引用
- Whitehouse ER, Peterson D, McCaffrey K, et al. Evaluation of Online Risk Assessment To Identify Rabies Exposures Among Health Care Workers - Utah, 2019. MMWR Morb Mortal Wkly Rep. 2020. PMID: 32701943. doi:10.15585/mmwr.mm6929a3
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。