赞比亚从10剂瓶换为5剂瓶MR疫苗对接种覆盖率和浪费的影响:混合方法研究
本研究在赞比亚两省14个地区采用混合方法,将地区配对后随机分配至5剂瓶或继续使用10剂瓶麻疹疫苗(MCV),通过倾向评分匹配双重差分分析覆盖率和浪费率。结果显示5剂瓶使MCV1覆盖率提高5个百分点、MCV2提高3.5个百分点,浪费率降低47%(16.2% vs 30.5%),医护人员更愿意为单个儿童开启5剂瓶。
要点
- 从10剂瓶换为5剂瓶可提高MCV1和MCV2覆盖率并大幅降低开启瓶浪费率。
- 5剂瓶设施浪费率为16.2%,显著低于10剂瓶的30.5%。
- 医护人员因担心浪费较少,更愿意为单个儿童开启5剂瓶。
核心结论
- 将10剂MCV瓶换为5剂瓶可提高接种覆盖率、降低开启瓶浪费率并改善医护人员开启意愿。
研究设计与样本
- 混合方法研究,在赞比亚两省目的性选取14个地区,按卫生设施数量和平均服务人口配对,每对中一个地区随机分配接受5剂瓶、另一个继续使用传统瓶。
- 采用倾向评分匹配双重差分分析,基于干预前家庭调查和干预11个月后的家庭调查估计覆盖率效应;浪费率效应通过行政数据的多变量分析估计。
- 在基线、中期和终点开展关键知情人访谈,采用主题分析法了解医护人员行为和偏好。
主要发现
- 两个组别的MCV两剂次覆盖率均上升,检测到MCV1的干预效应为5个百分点,MCV2为3.5个百分点。
- 使用5剂瓶的设施MCV浪费率为16.2%,比10剂瓶的30.5%低47%。
- 医护人员报告,相比10剂瓶,更愿意为单个儿童开启5剂瓶,因为对浪费的担忧较少。
关键数值与推荐
- MCV1干预效应:5个百分点;MCV2干预效应:3.5个百分点。
- 5剂瓶设施MCV浪费率16.2%,10剂瓶设施30.5%,前者低47%。
临床怎么用
- 在接种人数较少的场合,可考虑使用5剂瓶以减少因担心浪费而不开启瓶导致的错过接种机会。
- 换用5剂瓶可能有助于提高MCV覆盖率和降低疫苗浪费,可作为减少疫苗接种错过机会的策略之一。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: Vaccines procured for low-income countries are often packaged in multi-dose vials to reduce program costs. To avoid wastage, health workers may refrain from opening a vial if few children attend an immunization session, possibly leading to lower coverage. Lowering the number of doses in a vial may increase coverage and reduce wastage. METHODS: We used a mixed methods approach to measure the effects of switching from conventional 10-dose measles containing vaccine (MCV) vials to 5-dose MCV vials on coverage and open vial wastage in 14 districts purposely selected from two provinces in Zambia. The districts were paired based on the number of health facilities and the average size of the health facility catchment population. One district from each pair was randomly allocated to receive 5-dose vials while the other continued with the conventional vials. We applied propensity score matched difference-in-difference analysis to estimate intervention effects on coverage using pre-intervention household survey and post-intervention household survey after 11 months of the intervention. The intervention effects on wastage rates were estimated from multivariate analysis of the administrative data. Key informant interviews were conducted to better understand health workers' behavior and preferences at baseline, midline and endline, and analyzed using thematic analysis techniques. RESULTS: MCV coverage rates increased across both arms for both doses. A five percentage-point intervention effect was detected for MCV1 and 3.5 percentage-point effect for MCV2. The MCV wastage rate was 47% lower in facilities using 5-dose vials (16.2%) versus 10-dose vials (30.5%). Healthcare workers reported being more willing to open a 5-dose vial than a 10-dose vial for one child, as they were less concerned about wastage. DISCUSSION: Switching 10-dose MCV vials to 5-dose vials improved coverage, decreased wastage, and improved willingness to open a vial. These findings can contribute to strategies for reducing missed opportunities for vaccination.
引用
- Krudwig K, Knittel B, Karim A, et al. The effects of switching from 10 to 5-dose vials of MR vaccine on vaccination coverage and wastage: A mixed-method study in Zambia. Vaccine. 2020. PMID: 32703746. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2020.07.012
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。