法国疫苗犹豫在YouTube上的传播:信息特征分析
该研究检索YouTube上法语疫苗相关视频,筛选观看量至少1万次的视频,分析其对疫苗接种的态度及反疫苗论点。共纳入166个视频,其中120个(72.2%)为反疫苗视频,46个(27.8%)为支持疫苗视频;反疫苗视频观看量达5,129,215次,支持疫苗视频为2,371,048次。反疫苗视频最常用的论点为副作用(75.8%)、制药游说(61.3%)和佐剂存在(51.6%)。作者建议卫生专业人员与当局投资这些平台以准确告知用户并反驳反疫苗论点。
要点
- YouTube法语疫苗视频中反疫苗内容占72.2%,观看量远超支持疫苗视频。
- 反疫苗视频主要论点包括副作用、制药游说和佐剂。
- 卫生专业人员应参与平台建设以纠正疫苗错误信息。
核心结论
- 卫生专业人员应意识到互联网上广泛传播的疫苗错误信息。
- 卫生专业人员和卫生当局必须投资这些平台,可能与热门频道合作,以准确告知用户并反驳反疫苗视频提出的论点。
- 增加和维持疫苗接种使用对疫苗成功至关重要,尤其在疫苗犹豫强烈的法国。
研究设计与样本
- 通过关键词「vaccines」检索YouTube,识别法语且观看量至少10,000次的视频。
- 对每个视频收集描述性信息,包括对疫苗接种的意见。
- 收集2017年和2018年上传的反疫苗视频中使用的主要论点,以研究法国疫苗接种政策变化相关的反疫苗反应。
主要发现
- 共识别166个视频:120个(72.2%)被视为反疫苗视频,46个(27.8%)为支持疫苗视频。
- 92个(55%)视频于2017年至2018年间上传。
- 反疫苗视频被观看5,129,215次,支持疫苗视频被观看2,371,048次。
- 反疫苗最常用的三个论点:副作用(75.8%)、制药游说(61.3%)、佐剂存在(51.6%)。
临床怎么用
- 卫生专业人员应了解YouTube上广泛传播的疫苗错误信息。
- 卫生专业人员和卫生当局应投资这些平台,可能与热门频道合作,以准确告知用户并反驳反疫苗论点。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: This work characterises the information about vaccination available on YouTube™ in France. METHODS: YouTube™ (www.YouTube.com) was searched using "vaccines" as a keyword. Videos in French with at least 10,000 views were identified. For each video, specific descriptive information including the opinion on vaccination was identified. To study the anti-vaccine reaction linked to a change in French policy on vaccination, the main arguments used in videos with negative opinions on vaccination uploaded in 2017 and 2018 were also collected. RESULTS: We identified 166 videos: 120 (72.2%) were considered anti-vaccine videos and 46 (27.8%) were pro-vaccine; 92 (55%) were uploaded between 2017 and 2018. The anti-vaccine videos had been viewed 5,129,215 times and the pro-vaccine videos 2,371,048 times. The three most widely used anti-vaccination arguments were in regard to side effects (75.8%), pharmaceutical lobbying (61.3%), and the presence of adjuvants (51.6%). CONCLUSION: Health professionals should be aware of the widely disseminated vaccination misinformation available on the Internet. Health professionals and health authorities must invest in these platforms, perhaps in collaboration with popular channels, to inform users accurately and to refute arguments put forward by anti-vaccine videos. Increasing and maintaining vaccination use is vital for vaccines to achieve success, particularly in France where vaccine hesitancy is strong.
引用
- Lahouati M, De Coucy A, Sarlangue J, et al. Spread of vaccine hesitancy in France: What about YouTube™? Vaccine. 2020. PMID: 32682617. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2020.07.002
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。