流感疫苗选择退出政策可行吗?英格兰国家卫生服务体系实施者与管理者的证据
本研究通过半结构化访谈英格兰9家NHS信托机构的30名疫苗接种项目实施者和27名管理者,探讨2018/19赛季针对一线医护人员流感疫苗选择退出政策的可行性、可接受性和感知价值。结果显示该政策目的理解不足、数据使用不明,收集拒绝者信息造成劳资关系紧张,且无一家机构制定重新部署政策,结论认为该政策在样本机构中不可接受。
要点
- 选择退出政策目的沟通不清,实施者不知拒绝者数据如何被使用。
- 收集拒绝者个人信息并报告给直线管理者造成劳资关系紧张,导致拒绝填表和不执行政策。
- 无机构制定拒绝者的重新部署政策,认为因人员配备压力不切实际。
核心结论
- 在样本NHSTs中,针对医护人员的流感疫苗选择退出方法因目的信息不清和实施复杂而不可接受。
- 有效推广选择退出方法需明确沟通其目的是探索拒绝原因而非识别并推动拒绝者接种,以避免损害员工关系。
- NHSTs应让员工参与制定流感疫苗接种方法。
研究设计与样本
- 在英格兰9家2017/18赛季医护人员流感疫苗接种率不同的NHSTs进行半结构化访谈。
- 访谈了30名疫苗接种项目实施者和27名管理者。
主要发现
- 政策目的理解不足,受访者不知道拒绝者数据如何被使用。
- 多数NHSTs尝试收集拒绝者个人信息,有时记录在电子员工记录中并报告给直线管理者采取行动。
- 收集信息造成雇主-雇员关系紧张,导致拒绝者拒绝填写选择退出表格,一些接种者不实施政策。
- 没有NHST有拒绝者的重新部署政策,认为因人员配备水平压力不切实际。
临床怎么用
- 实施选择退出方法时应清晰沟通其目的是探索拒绝原因而非识别并推动拒绝者接种。
- 应让员工参与制定流感疫苗接种方法以避免损害员工关系。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: In 2018/19, English NHS trusts (NHSTs) implemented an 'opt-out' policy for seasonal flu vaccination in frontline healthcare workers (HCWs). HCWs declining the vaccination were asked to sign an opt-out form and provide a reason for their decision. In addition, HCWs working in higher risk hospital environments (e.g. oncology) were asked to inform their manager about their declination decision. The policy aimed to provide greater insight into reasons for vaccination decline and information from HCWs in higher risk areas was intended for use in considering HCW redeployment. This study investigated the feasibility, acceptability, and perceived value of the policy during the 2018/19 flu vaccination season. METHODS: We conducted semi-structured interviews across 9 NHSTs in England with different levels of HCW flu vaccination uptake in 2017/18. We interviewed 30 vaccination programme implementers and 27 managers. FINDINGS: The purpose of the policy was poorly understood, and interviewees did not know how data on decliners was being used. Most NHSTs tried to collect the personal details of decliners and, in some instances, these were recorded in Electronic Staff Records and reported to line-managers for action. This created strain on employer-employee relationships, leading to decliners refusing to complete opt-out forms and some vaccinators not implementing the policy. None of the NHSTs had a redeployment policy for decliners, arguing that this was impractical due to strain on staffing levels. CONCLUSION: A flu-vaccination opt-out approach for HCWs did not appear acceptable in our sampled NHSTs, due to a lack of clear messaging about its purpose and complicated implementation. To promote an opt-out approach effectively, there needs to be clear communication of its purpose, which should be to explore reasons for decline rather than identify and 'push' decliners to vaccinate, so as not to damage staff relationships. NHSTs should involve their workforce in developing flu vaccination approaches.
引用
- Bell S, Chantler T, Paterson P, et al. Is flu vaccination opt-out feasible? Evidence from vaccination programme implementers and managers in the English National Health Service. Vaccine. 2020. PMID: 32381480. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2020.04.026
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。