从糟糕到更糟:HPV疫苗在Facebook上的表征
该研究分析了FDA首次批准HPV疫苗后十年内6506条公开Facebook帖子,发现 barriers 信息(47.1%)多于 benefits(19.8%),负面语气主导(45.0%),平均情绪为负(M=-0.15,SD=0.851)。负面语气与疫苗障碍呈负相关(r=-0.631,p<0.0001),参与度最高的帖子为反HPV疫苗,且负面帖子获得显著更高参与。随时间推移,负面语气和障碍信息存在更大存在。
要点
- HPV疫苗相关Facebook帖子以负面为主,障碍信息多于益处信息。
- 负面帖子获得更高参与度,最高参与帖子为反疫苗内容。
- 随时间推移,负面语气和障碍信息呈现增加趋势。
核心结论
- HPV疫苗相关Facebook帖子多为负面,常聚焦于接种障碍。
- 时间效应表明反HPV疫苗帖子鼓励了更多反HPV疫苗帖子。
研究设计与样本
- 研究样本为FDA首次批准HPV疫苗后十年内(2006年6月8日至2016年6月8日)发布的6506条公开HPV疫苗相关Facebook帖子。
- 对帖子特征、参与度和健康信念模型(HBM)信息进行编码(Krippendorf's alpha范围:0.71-1.00)。
主要发现
- HPV疫苗接种障碍信息出现频率(47.1%)高于益处信息(19.8%)。
- 对疫苗的语气以负面为主(45.0%),样本平均情绪为负(M=-0.15,SD=0.851)。
- 语气积极性与HPV疫苗障碍呈负相关(r=-0.631,p<0.0001)。
- 参与度最高的帖子(显示11000次反应、6100条评论和329000次分享)为反HPV疫苗,负面帖子获得显著更高参与。
- 随时间推移,负面语气和障碍信息存在更大存在;数据显示HPV感染易感性(0.004)、HPV感染严重性(0.426)、HPV疫苗益处(0.297)、接种障碍(0.226)、语气(0.690)、反应数(1.589)、评论数(1.389)和分享数(1.340)的Durbin-Watson值有前向动量证据。
临床怎么用
- 应关注社交媒体上HPV疫苗负面信息对疫苗犹豫和回避的影响。
- 需测试亲HPV疫苗但语气负面、涉及障碍或由个体利益相关者呈现的信息在社交媒体内外的效果。
局限性
- 研究应继续解决时间的影响。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Anti-HPV vaccination social media messages may increase vaccine hesitancy and avoidance. This study analyzed (1) the first decade of public, HPV-vaccine related Facebook posts' characteristics, engagement, and health belief messages; (2) relationships between variables; (3) how those variables changed over time; and (4) identified and analyzed the posts with the most engagement. METHODS: The data sample consisted of 6,506 public HPV vaccine-related Facebook posts (n = 6,506) published within the first decade following the FDA's first HPV vaccine approval (June 8, 2006 - June 8, 2016). Post characteristics, engagement, and health belief model (HBM) messages were coded (Krippendorf's alpha range: 0.71-1.00). RESULTS: Barriers to HPV vaccination appeared more often (47.1%) than benefits (19.8%). Regarding the tone towards the vaccine, negative was dominant (45.0%) and the average sample sentiment was negative (M = -0.15, SD = 0.851). Tone positivity was negatively correlated with barriers to HPV vaccine (r = -0.631, p < 0.0001). The post with the most engagement (11,000 reactions, 6,100 comments, and 329,000 shares displayed) was anti-HPV vaccine, and negative posts received significantly greater engagement. Over time, negative tone and barriers had a greater presence. The data showed evidence for forward momentum (Durbin-Watson values) of HPV infection susceptibility (0.004), HPV infection severity (0.426), HPV vaccine benefits (0.297), and barriers to HPV vaccination (0.226) messages, tone (0.690), and the number of reactions (1.589), comments (1.389), and shares (1.340). CONCLUSION: Facebook posts about the HPV vaccine were mostly negative with a frequent focus on barriers to vaccination. Time effects suggest that anti-HPV vaccine posts have encouraged more anti-HPV vaccine posts. Research should continue to address the influence of time. The influence of messages that are pro-HPV vaccine, but perhaps are negative in tone, address barriers, and/or presented by individual stakeholders, should be tested inside and outside of social media channels.
引用
- Luisi MLR. From bad to worse: The representation of the HPV vaccine Facebook. Vaccine. 2020. PMID: 32417141. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2020.05.016
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。