文献速递卫生政策与健康促进免疫规划

全球疫苗行动计划经验教训III:监测评估与问责框架

Global Vaccine Action Plan lessons learned III: Monitoring and evaluation/accountability framework.
PubMed 文献 · Vaccine · 2020-05-16

该研究通过2017至2019年开展的五轮审查(含问卷调查与半结构化访谈)收集利益相关方反馈,评估全球疫苗行动计划(GVAP)监测评估与问责(M&E/A)框架。反馈褒贬不一且部分矛盾,多数人认为该流程是GVAP亮点和正确方向,但部分目标不切实际,对问责的促进作用尤其在国家层面评价不一。

要点

  • 多数利益相关方认为GVAP的监测评估与问责流程是亮点和正确方向。
  • 若干目标与指标被认为过于理想化,对许多国家不切实际。
  • 该流程提升了免疫的全球议程地位,但未完全满足促进问责的期望。

核心结论

  • 利益相关方对GVAP监测评估与问责流程及其影响的看法褒贬不一且相互矛盾,提示该流程在范围与意图的沟通上存在不足。
  • 该流程尤其是年度向世界卫生大会报告,使免疫接种在全球议程中保持高位,但未能完全满足促进问责的期望。
  • 未来十年需与国家合作在设定全球目标时纳入本地情境,并推动本地监测评估与问责流程以实现问责。

研究设计与样本

  • 通过2017至2019年开展的五轮审查收集利益相关方反馈,审查由问卷调查与半结构化访谈组成。
  • 参与者包括参与GVAP或其监测评估与问责流程制定与实施的人员、国家免疫规划管理者、学者、非政府组织代表及民间社会组织代表。

主要发现

  • 反馈褒贬不一,部分组成部分的意见相互矛盾。
  • 多数参与者报告监测评估与问责流程是GVAP的亮点,是朝着正确方向迈出的一步。
  • 若干目标与指标被认为过于理想化,对许多国家不切实际。
  • 关于该流程是否促进问责,尤其在国家层面,反馈不一。

临床怎么用

  • 在设定全球疫苗目标与指标时应与国家合作纳入本地情境。
  • 应推动本地监测评估与问责流程以促进问责。
  • 需加强关于监测评估与问责流程范围与意图的沟通。

局限性

  • 反馈存在褒贬不一和相互矛盾,部分组成部分意见不一致。
  • 对问责促进作用的评价不一,尤其在国家层面。
  • 看法矛盾提示流程范围与意图的沟通存在不足。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

INTRODUCTION: The Monitoring & Evaluation/Accountability (M&E/A) framework of the Global Vaccine Action Plan (GVAP) was used to report progress annually to the World Health Assembly (WHA). METHODS: Stakeholder feedback was obtained through five reviews consisting of surveys and semi-structured interviews conducted from 2017 to 2019. Participants consisted of individuals involved in the development and implementation of GVAP or its M&E/A process, national immunization managers, academics, representatives of non-governmental organizations, and civil society organizations. RESULTS: The feedback was mixed and contradictory for some components, though most participants reported that the M&E/A process was a highlight of GVAP and a step in the right direction. Several of the goals and targets were considered aspirational and unrealistic for many countries. There were mixed responses on whether it promoted accountability, especially at the country level. DISCUSSION: The mixed and contradictory views on the M&E/A processes and its impact suggested a failure of communication about its scope and intent. Though the process, especially the annual reporting to the WHA, kept immunization high on the global agenda, it failed to fully meet the expectations in promoting accountability. Engaging with countries to capture the local context in setting global goals and targets and promoting local M&E/A processes will be important to achieve accountability in the next decade.

来源:Vaccine,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Cherian T, Hwang A, Mantel C, et al. Global Vaccine Action Plan lessons learned III: Monitoring and evaluation/accountability framework. Vaccine. 2020. PMID: 32430149. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2020.05.028

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。