ADVANCE系统测试:暴露数据不完整时估算百日咳疫苗接种后不良事件发生率
ADVANCE项目评估在部分医疗数据库缺乏疫苗接种暴露数据时,利用其他数据库的估算IR和IRR推导接种后风险期IR的方法。针对0-5岁儿童首发无细胞百日咳疫苗后的热性惊厥、发热和持续哭闹,比较三种推导法与观察IR,发现数据库类型和事件捕获方式会影响潜在偏倚。
要点
- 暴露数据缺失时可利用其他数据库的IRR或背景IR推导接种后风险期IR。
- 热性惊厥IR在初级保健数据库低于医院数据库,推导方向随之偏移。
- 建议仅用同类数据库推导IR,但结果仍可能异质。
核心结论
- 接种后风险期缺失的IR可被推导,但数据库类型和事件数据捕获方式会影响潜在偏倚。
- 建议谨慎使用同类数据库(医院或初级保健)数据推导IR,即使如此结果仍可能异质。
研究设计与样本
- 基于四个初级保健数据库和一个医院数据库,估算0-5岁儿童首发aP疫苗接种后结局特异性风险期和非风险期的IR。
- 比较三种推导IR方法与观察IR:非风险期IR乘以其他数据库Meta分析IRR、非风险期IR乘以背景IR、其他数据库观察IR的Meta分析。
主要发现
- 热性惊厥IR在初级保健数据库低于医院数据库。
- 用初级保健数据库数据推导的热性惊厥IR低于医院数据库观察值,用医院数据库数据推导则高于初级保健数据库观察值。
- 发热和持续哭闹的推导方向与热性惊厥相反。
临床怎么用
- 在暴露数据不完整的数据库中估算接种后不良事件IR时,应优先使用同类数据库数据并谨慎解读。
- 需考虑数据库类型和事件捕获方式对推导IR潜在偏倚的影响。
局限性
- 仅涉及热性惊厥、发热和持续哭闹三个结局,外推需谨慎。
- 推导IR受数据库类型和事件数据捕获方式影响,可能产生异质结果。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
The Accelerated Development of VAccine beNefit-risk Collaboration in Europe (ADVANCE) is a public-private collaboration aiming to develop and test a system for rapid vaccine benefit-risk monitoring using existing European healthcare databases. Incidence rate (IR) estimates of vaccination-associated adverse events that are needed to model vaccination risks can be calculated from existing healthcare databases when vaccination (exposure) data are available. We assessed different methods to derive IRs in risk periods following vaccination when exposure data are missing in one database, using estimated IRs and IRRs from other databases for febrile seizures, fever and persistent crying. IRs were estimated for children aged 0-5 years in outcome-specific risk and non-risk periods following the first dose of acellular pertussis (aP) vaccination in four primary care databases and one hospital database. We compared derived and observed IRs in each database using three methods: 1) multiplication of non-risk period IR for database i by IR ratio (IRR) obtained from meta-analysis of IRRs estimated using the self-controlled case-series method, from databases other than i; 2) same method as 1, but multiplying with background IR; and 3) meta-analyses of observed IRs from databases other than i. IRs for febrile seizures were lower in primary care databases than the hospital database. The derived IR for febrile seizures using data from primary care databases was lower than that observed in the hospital database, and using data from the hospital database gave a higher derived IR than that observed in the primary care database. For fever and persistent crying the opposite was observed. We demonstrated that missing IRs for a post-vaccination period can be derived but that the type of database and the method of event data capture can have an impact on potential bias. We recommend IRs are derived using data from similar database types (hospital or primary care) with caution as even this can give heterogeneous results.
引用
- Dodd C, de Ridder M, Weibel D, et al. ADVANCE system testing: Estimating the incidence of adverse events following pertussis vaccination in healthcare databases with incomplete exposure data. Vaccine. 2020. PMID: 32280043. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2020.03.050
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。