影响英格兰国民医疗服务体系急性医院信托机构员工流感疫苗接种绩效的组织因素:一项定性研究
世界卫生组织推荐医务人员为季节性流感疫苗优先接种人群。英格兰2017/18年度医务人员总体接种率为69.5%,但各信托机构间从50%到超过92.3%不等。本定性研究在9家接种率从略高于55%到超过90%的医院访谈57名管理者和接种人员,探讨接种率差异的组织原因并为低绩效信托机构提供改进建议。
要点
- 各信托机构均部署了多种需求创造与供应干预措施,但组织与实施模式存在显著差异。
- 组织文化可能是区分高绩效与低绩效信托机构的最重要因素。
- 将流感疫苗接种嵌入组织健康策略而非作为孤立季节性项目实施,倾向于促进良好绩效。
核心结论
- 组织文化可能是区分高绩效与低绩效信托机构的最重要因素。
- 以促进持续改进和偏向非强制为目标的积极文化总体上带来员工更高的依从性。
- 将流感疫苗接种嵌入组织健康策略而非作为孤立季节性项目实施,倾向于促进良好绩效。
- 改善医务人员流感疫苗接种绩效不仅涉及部署正确干预措施和遵循最佳实践,还需要使流感项目实施策略适应组织情境,并将疫苗接种嵌入组织文化以支持年度接种常态化。
研究设计与样本
- 定性研究,在英格兰9家流感疫苗接种率从略高于55%到超过90%的医院中访谈57名管理者和接种人员。
主要发现
- 各信托机构部署了广泛的需求创造与供应干预措施以提高接种率,但所采用的组织与实施模式存在显著差异。
- 组织文化可能是区分高绩效与低绩效信托机构的最重要因素。
- 以促进持续改进和偏向非强制为目标的积极文化总体上带来员工更高的依从性。
- 将流感疫苗接种嵌入组织健康策略而非作为孤立季节性项目实施,倾向于促进良好绩效。
临床怎么用
- 作者建议低绩效信托机构参考本研究结果改进流感疫苗接种绩效。
- 作者认为改善绩效需要使流感项目实施策略适应组织情境,并将疫苗接种嵌入组织文化以支持年度接种常态化。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Health care workers are a priority group for seasonal influenza vaccination, which is recommended by the World Health Organisation. There is a wide variation in uptake between and within countries. England has achieved 69.5% of health care workers vaccinated overall in 2017/18 across NHS acute and community health care settings, but it varies between Trusts from 50% to over 92.3%. While attitudinal factors have been well researched, there is limited evidence on organisational factors associated with high uptake. In England, most NHS Trusts are now implementing a similar range of interventions as part of their flu programme, and it remains unclear why performance remains so variable. This qualitative study is the first to explore reasons for this variation and provide recommendations for lower performing Trusts on how to improve. Fifty-seven interviews of managers and vaccinators were conducted in nine hospitals with flu vaccination uptake ranging from just over 55% to above 90%. Our study found that while Trusts deployed a wide range of both demand generating and supply interventions to increase uptake, there were marked differences in the organisational and delivery models utilised. Our study suggests that organisational culture was possibly the most important ingredient when trying to differentiate between high and low performing Trusts. We found that a positive culture aimed at fostering continuous improvement and favouring non-coercion on balance yielded more adherence from staff. Where influenza vaccination was embedded in the organisation wellbeing strategy, rather than executed as a siloed seasonal programme, this tended to foster good performance. Improving performance of influenza vaccination in health care workers will involve not only deploying the right interventions, and following "best practices". It will require the adaptation of flu progamme delivery strategies to the organisation context, and embedding vaccination into the organisational culture, thus supporting the normalisation of yearly vaccination.
引用
- Mounier-Jack S, Bell S, Chantler T, et al. Organisational factors affecting performance in delivering influenza vaccination to staff in NHS Acute Hospital Trusts in England: A qualitative study. Vaccine. 2020. PMID: 32147294. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2020.02.077
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。