文献速递免疫规划妇幼与学校卫生卫生政策与健康促进

关于流感疫苗的媒体报道对产科医生疫苗接种实践的影响

Impact of media reports regarding influenza vaccine on obstetricians' vaccination practices.
PubMed 文献 · Vaccine · 2020-03-21

2018年4月至6月对美国全国代表性产科医生样本进行调查,应答率65%(302/468)。媒体报道强调流感严重性可能比质疑疫苗安全性或有效性的报道对产科医生推荐行为影响更大,35%的医生因流产研究报道增加对疫苗安全性的担忧,18%改变了推荐方式。

要点

  • 88%的产科医生非常了解严重流感季节,74%了解疫苗有效性降低,仅25%了解流产研究。
  • 83%的医生同意严重性报道增加推荐流感疫苗的热情,18%因流产研究报道增加安全性担忧。
  • 18%(n=48)改变推荐方式,其中17人(占全部6%)不推荐孕早期接种,26人(占全部10%)推荐但愿意推迟至孕中期。

核心结论

  • 在媒体报道可能以不同方向影响产科医生流感疫苗接种行为的季节,强调流感疫苗重要性的报道可能比质疑疫苗安全性或有效性的报道对产科医生推荐的影响更大。

研究设计与样本

  • 2018年4月至6月对美国全国代表性产科医生样本进行调查,应答率65%(302/468)。

主要发现

  • 88%的产科医生非常了解严重流感季节,74%了解疫苗有效性降低,25%了解流产研究(47%完全不知道流产研究)。
  • 在知晓者中,分别有58%、57%和16%报告至少10%的孕妇患者主动讨论了严重季节、有效性降低和流产研究。
  • 83%的医生同意关于严重性增加的报道增加了他们推荐流感疫苗的热情;较少医生同意流产研究报道(18%)和疫苗有效性降低报道(12%)降低了他们推荐流感疫苗的热情。
  • 35%的医生同意流产研究报道增加了他们对流感疫苗安全性的担忧;18%(n=48)报告改变了推荐流感疫苗的方式。
  • 在改变推荐方式的医生中,17人(占全部受访者的6%)报告不推荐孕早期妇女接种流感疫苗,26人(占全部受访者的10%)推荐但愿意推迟至孕中期。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: In 2017, three media stories regarding influenza vaccine may have impacted obstetricians' (OB) influenza vaccination practices: reports of reduced influenza vaccine effectiveness, a severe influenza season, and a possible increased risk of miscarriage among pregnant women receiving 2009 H1N1 vaccine in the 1st trimester who had received H1N1 vaccine the previous season (later disproven). OBJECTIVE: Describe OB's: (1) awareness of; (2) attitudes and experiences related to; and (3) reported alterations in practice as a result of these reports. METHODS: A survey among a nationally representative sample of OBs April to June 2018. RESULTS: Response rate was 65% (302/468). 88% of OBs were "very aware" of the severe season, 74% of lower effectiveness, and 25% of the miscarriage study (47% "completely unaware" of miscarriage study). Among those aware, 58%, 57%, and 16% reported ≥10% of pregnant patients initiated discussions about the severe season, lower effectiveness, and miscarriage study, respectively. Most (83%) agreed reports about increased severity increased their enthusiasm for recommending influenza vaccine; fewer agreed reports about the miscarriage study (18%) and lower vaccine effectiveness (12%) decreased their enthusiasm for recommending influenza vaccine. Providers were more likely to initiate discussion with patients about increased severity of the season than the other reports. However, 35% agreed the miscarriage study reports increased their concerns about influenza vaccine safety; 18% (n = 48) reported changing the way they recommended influenza vaccine. Of those, 17 (6% of all respondents) reported not recommending influenza vaccine to women during the 1st trimester and 26 (10% of all respondents) recommended it but were willing to delay until the 2nd trimester. CONCLUSIONS: During a season in which media stories could have influenced OB influenza vaccination behaviors in different directions, reports underscoring importance of influenza vaccine may have had more impact on OBs' recommendations than reports questioning vaccine safety or effectiveness.

来源:Vaccine,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. O'Leary ST, Cataldi JR, Lindley MC, et al. Impact of media reports regarding influenza vaccine on obstetricians' vaccination practices. Vaccine. 2020. PMID: 32204941. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2020.02.051

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。