文献速递免疫规划卫生政策与健康促进

向EudraVigilance报告的免疫接种差错后致死性结局:病例系列分析

Fatal outcomes following immunization errors as reported to the EudraVigilance: A case series.
PubMed 文献 · Vaccine · 2020-03-05

该研究系统回顾了EudraVigilance数据库中报告免疫接种差错并导致致死性结局的个体病例安全报告,共纳入154份报告,由两名独立评审员用WHO因果关联评估工具进行评价。结果显示,12例被判定为与因果关联一致且差错贡献大,涉及含麻疹疫苗多剂量瓶处理不当的6例聚集性病例和给免疫功能低下患者接种减毒活疫苗的6例。作者指出免疫接种差错后致死性结局非常罕见,并提出质量控制、筛查免疫抑制因素、教育依从性和改进疫苗与药品区分四项关键问题。

要点

  • 免疫接种差错后致死性结局极为罕见,但可对公众信任造成巨大影响。
  • 最常见的报告差错为未遵循推荐免疫程序(63例),最常见的疫苗-差错组合为狂犬病疫苗与未遵循推荐程序(23例)。
  • 12例被判定为因果关联一致且差错贡献大,涉及麻疹疫苗多剂量瓶处理不当和给免疫功能低下者接种减毒活疫苗。

核心结论

  • 免疫接种差错后致死性结局非常罕见。
  • 作者提出四项关键问题:多剂量疫苗质量控制、筛查患者免疫抑制因素、依从性教育以及改进疫苗与药品的区分措施。

研究设计与样本

  • 本研究为病例系列分析,系统回顾EudraVigilance中报告免疫接种差错并伴致死性结局的个体病例安全报告。
  • 共纳入154份符合入选标准的个体病例安全报告,由两名独立评审员使用WHO工具「免疫接种后不良事件因果关联评估」评价因果关联确定性,并按本研究制定的分类评估差错对致死性结局的贡献大小。

主要发现

  • 报告最多的疫苗为肺炎球菌疫苗(33例)、狂犬病疫苗(27例)和流感疫苗(24例)。
  • 报告最多的差错为未遵循推荐免疫程序(63例),最常见的疫苗-差错组合为狂犬病疫苗与未遵循推荐免疫程序(23例)。
  • 12例被判定为与因果关联一致且差错贡献大,涉及含麻疹疫苗多剂量瓶处理不当的6例聚集性病例和给免疫功能低下患者接种减毒活疫苗的6例。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Serious adverse reactions after immunization are rare but do occur. In very rare instances, cases with fatal outcome have been reported. These reports can have a huge impact and even more so when due to an immunization error. The aim of this study is to systematically review immunization errors with fatal outcomes in EudraVigilance. METHODS: This was a case-series analysis of Individual Case Safety Reports (ICSRs) reporting immunization errors and a fatal outcome. To determine the level of certainty of a causal association between the immunization errors and fatal outcomes two independent reviewers assessed all ICSRs using the WHO tool "Causality assessment of an Adverse Event Following Immunization (AEFI)". In accordance with the tool, the ICSRs were classified as consistent, indeterminate, inconsistent/coincidental, or unclassifiable. In addition, we estimated the contribution of reported errors to the fatal outcomes as large, moderate, small, none, or unclassifiable using a classification developed for this study. RESULTS: A total of 154 ICSRs met the inclusion criteria. Vaccines reported most frequently were pneumococcal (33), rabies (27) and influenza vaccines (24). Most frequently reported errors were non-compliance with recommended schedules of immunization (63). The most frequently reported vaccine-error combination was rabies vaccines and non-compliance with a recommended schedule of immunization (23). Twelve cases were classified as consistent with causal association and had a large error contribution. These cases concerned a cluster of six cases reporting incorrect handling of multi-dose vials containing measles vaccine and six cases reporting administration of live-attenuated vaccines to immunocompromised patients. DISCUSSION: In this study, we showed that fatal outcomes following immunization errors are very rare. Four key issues were the importance of: (1) quality control of multi-dose vaccines, (2) screening patients for immunocompromising factors, (3) education on the importance of adherence, and (4) measures to improve distinction between vaccines and medicines.

来源:Vaccine,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Hoeve CE, Gadroen K, Kwa MSG, et al. Fatal outcomes following immunization errors as reported to the EudraVigilance: A case series. Vaccine. 2020. PMID: 32147297. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2020.02.074

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。