关于疫苗效力的新见解:减毒猪繁殖与呼吸综合征疫苗株免疫对异源毒株传播的影响
通过两项连续传播试验共52头猪,评估猪繁殖与呼吸综合征(PRRS)候选疫苗株对强毒异源毒株水平传播的效力。接种未能阻止感染和排毒,但延迟病毒血症出现、缩短排毒持续时间并显著降低整个感染期的病毒载量;贝叶斯模型显示接种组R0较低但可信区间大幅重叠。
要点
- 接种未能防止猪感染和排出异源PRRS毒株。
- 接种延迟病毒血症出现、缩短排毒时间并显著降低病毒载量。
- 接种组R0较低,但两组可信区间大幅重叠。
核心结论
- 结果表明,即使疫苗不能预防感染,仍可对传播动力学产生有益影响并有助于降低猪群的R0。
- 但还需考虑生物安全和其他措施以降低接触率并使R0低于1。
研究设计与样本
- 开展了两项连续的传播试验,共涉及52头猪,评估PRRS候选疫苗株对强毒异源毒株水平传播的效力。
- 拟合贝叶斯流行病学模型评估接种和血清无应答(NSR)存在对PRRS病毒传播动力学的影响。
主要发现
- 除一头猪外(该例外仅血清检测阳性),所有猪的血清和鼻分泌物中均观察到超过规定检测限的PRRS病毒。
- 接种延迟了病毒血症的出现,缩短了排毒持续时间,并显著降低了整个感染期的病毒载量。
- 一项试验中13头接种猪有4头(31%)无血清学应答(NSR)。
- 尽管减少传播率的证据很少,接种动物平均成为传染性更慢、传染期更短且恢复更快。
- 接种动物的总体PRRSV传播潜力(以繁殖比R0表示)较低,但两组可信区间有大幅重叠。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Vaccination is the main tool for controlling infectious diseases in livestock. Yet current vaccines only provide partial protection raising concerns about vaccine effectiveness in the field. Two successive transmission trials were performed involving 52 pigs to evaluate the effectiveness of a Porcine Reproductive and Respiratory Syndrome (PRRS) vaccinal strain candidate against horizontal transmission of a virulent heterologous strain. PRRS virus, above the specified limit of detection, was observed in serum and nasal secretions for all but one pig (the exception only tested positive for serum), indicating that vaccination did not protect pigs from becoming infected and shedding the heterologous strain. However, vaccination delayed the onset of viraemia, reduced the duration of shedding and significantly decreased viral load throughout infection. Serum antibody profiles indicated that 4 out of 13 (31%) vaccinates in one trial had no serological response (NSR). A Bayesian epidemiological model was fitted to the data to assess the impact of vaccination and presence of NSRs on PRRS virus transmission dynamics. Despite little evidence for reduction in the transmission rate, vaccinated animals were on average slower to become infectious, experienced a shorter infectious period and recovered faster. The overall PRRSV transmission potential, represented by the reproductive ratio R0 was lower for the vaccinated animals, although there was substantial overlap in the credibility intervals for both groups. Model selection suggests that transmission parameters of vaccinated pigs with NSR were more similar to those of unvaccinated animals. The presence of NSRs in a population, however, seemed to only marginally affect the transmission dynamics. The results suggest that even when vaccination can't prevent infection, it can still have beneficial impacts on the transmission dynamics and contribute to reducing a herd's R0. However, biosecurity and other measures need to be considered to decrease contact rates and lower R0 below 1.
引用
- Chase-Topping M, Xie J, Pooley C, et al. New insights about vaccine effectiveness: Impact of attenuated PRRS-strain vaccination on heterologous strain transmission. Vaccine. 2020. PMID: 32122719. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2020.02.015
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。