社交问答服务中的疫苗信息寻求行为
研究分析两个社交问答平台上的4910个问题和2583个答案,考察疫苗相关提问类型及答案质量感知特征。结果显示不同平台提问主题不同,多数提问未指定专业或家长经验来源,但健康专业人员撰写的答案在Yahoo! Answers上被选为最佳答案的可能性翻倍。在线实验表明回答者身份和疫苗立场均影响信任感知。
要点
- 不同社交问答平台上疫苗相关问题的主题焦点不同。
- 多数提问未明确要求答案基于专业 expertise 或家长经验。
- 健康专业人员撰写的答案在Yahoo! Answers上被选为最佳答案的可能性是其他答案的两倍。
核心结论
- 尽管抗疫苗信息增多,对主流科学和医学的认识论信任仍然稳固。
- 用户对专家答案的反应表明,在线环境中的专家外展可能是应对疫苗犹豫的有效干预措施。
研究设计与样本
- 研究从两个社交问答平台「Yahoo! Answers」和Facebook群组「Talking about Vaccines」检索了4910个问题和2583个答案。
- 基于认识论信任理论,分析提问类型、提问是否明确指向健康专业人员或家长,以及答案特征对感知答案质量的预测。
- 另进行了一项在线实验,考察回答者身份和疫苗立场对信任感知的影响。
主要发现
- 在一个平台上,疫苗相关问题聚焦于疫苗接种的风险和益处,而在另一个平台上则涉及接种时间表。
- 在两个平台上,多数问题未指定答案应基于专业 expertise 或家长经验。
- 支持和反对疫苗的答案在「最佳答案」中比例相当。
- 在Yahoo! Answers上,由健康专业人员撰写的答案被提问者和社区选为疫苗相关问题的「最佳答案」的可能性是其他答案的两倍,无论该答案是鼓励还是 discouraging 接种疫苗。
- 在线实验显示,回答者的身份和对疫苗接种的立场均影响答案的感知可信度。
临床怎么用
- 用户对专家答案的反应提示,在线环境中的专家外展可能作为应对疫苗犹豫的有效干预措施。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Experts are concerned about the spread and recalcitrance of vaccine misinformation and its contribution to vaccine hesitancy. Despite this risk, little research attention has been paid to understanding how individuals seek vaccine information online and evaluate its trustworthiness. Here, we hypothesized that when vaccine-hesitant parents seek information about vaccines, they prefer trustworthy sources based on their competence, integrity and benevolence. We explored this issue using 4910 questions and 2583 answers retrieved from two social question-and-answer (Q&A) platforms: "Yahoo! Answers" and the Facebook group "Talking about Vaccines." We examined what kinds of questions are asked about vaccines, to what extent they are explicitly directed at health professionals or parents, and what features of the answers predict perceived answer quality, based on the theory of epistemic trust. The findings indicate that on different platforms, vaccine-related questions focus on different topics; namely, questions on one platform focused on the risks and benefits of vaccination, whereas they dealt with vaccine schedules on the other. On both platforms, most questions did not specify that an answer should be based on professional expertise or parents' experience. Both pro-vaccine and anti-vaccine answers were proportionately represented among the "best answers". However, if an answer was written by a health professional, the askers and the community on "Yahoo! Answers" were twice as likely to choose it as the "best answer" to a vaccine-related question, irrespective of whether it encouraged or discouraged vaccination. By contrast, an online experiment revealed that both the identity of the respondent and the stance towards vaccination affected the perceived trustworthiness of the answers. These findings indicate that despite the proliferation of anti-vaccine messages, epistemic trust in mainstream science and medicine is robust. User responses to expert answers suggest that expert outreach in online environments may be an effective intervention to address vaccine hesitancy.
引用
- Sharon AJ, Yom-Tov E, Baram-Tsabari A, et al. Vaccine information seeking on social Q&A services. Vaccine. 2020. PMID: 32061384. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2020.02.010
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。