识别疫苗接种的障碍与驱动因素:对波斯尼亚和黑塞哥维那联邦卫生工作者的定性访谈研究
在波斯尼亚和黑塞哥维那疫苗接种覆盖率下降的背景下,作为世界卫生组织定制免疫规划(TIP)项目的一部分,本研究对38名卫生工作者进行面对面定性访谈,探讨其对儿童疫苗接种实践的障碍与驱动因素。访谈资料用内容分析并按能力、机会和动机(COM)因素归纳。结果显示高覆盖率与低覆盖率初级保健中心之间及不同职业角色之间障碍与驱动因素差异甚微,障碍与驱动因素复杂且相互关联,将用于确定和优先排序干预措施。
要点
- 高覆盖率与低覆盖率初级保健中心之间及不同职业角色之间障碍与驱动因素差异甚微。
- 能力障碍包括使用错误禁忌症推迟接种及调整与家长沟通的技巧不足。
- 机会障碍包括未实施强制接种、缺乏统一召回提醒系统及人员短缺。
核心结论
- 研究识别出卫生工作者积极疫苗接种实践存在复杂且相互关联的障碍与驱动因素,这些见解将用于确定和优先排序干预措施。
研究设计与样本
- 对38名卫生工作者进行面对面定性访谈,探讨其对疫苗接种覆盖率、接种态度及系统、项目和机构对其接种实践影响的看法。
- 数据采用内容分析,并按能力、机会和动机(COM)因素归纳。
主要发现
- 高覆盖率与低覆盖率初级保健中心之间及不同职业角色之间障碍与驱动因素差异甚微。
- 能力驱动因素包括对低接种覆盖率风险的认识、常规使用规则手册和命令、了解如何就轻微副作用向家长提供建议以及认识到与家长良好沟通的重要性。
- 能力障碍包括使用错误禁忌症推迟接种和调整与家长沟通的技巧不足。
- 机会驱动因素包括有足够时间实施接种和疫苗可获得性良好;机会障碍包括未实施强制接种、没有统一的召回提醒系统或检测未充分接种儿童的系统、人员短缺和缺乏时间与家长讨论疫苗接种。
- 动机驱动因素包括相信疫苗接种的价值、安全性和有效性以及认识到自身发挥重要作用;动机障碍包括倾向归咎外部因素(如反疫苗运动)和害怕因不良事件被指责。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Vaccination coverage in Bosnia and Herzegovina has been declining over recent years. A World Health Organization Tailoring Immunization Programmes (TIP) project is underway to gain insights into the underlying reasons for this, to develop tailored interventions. As part of TIP, this study aimed to investigate the views of health workers on their barriers and drivers to positive childhood vaccination practices. METHODS: Face-to-face qualitative interviews explored 38 health workers' views on vaccination coverage, their vaccination attitudes, and system, programme and institutional influences on their vaccination practices. The data were analysed using content analysis and organised by the COM (Capability, Opportunity and Motivation) factors. FINDINGS: Very few differences in barriers and drivers were evident between high and low coverage primary care centres or across different professional roles. Capability: Drivers included awareness of the risks of low vaccination coverage, regular use of the Rulebook and Order, knowledge of how to advise parents on mild side effects and recognition of the importance of good communication with parents. Key barriers were the use of false contraindications to postpone vacination and poor skills in tailoring communication with parents. Opportunity: Drivers were sufficient time for adminstering vaccination and good availability of vaccines. Several barriers were evident: lack of implementation of mandatory vaccination, no uniform recall and reminder system or system for detecting under-vaccinated children, staff shortages and lack of time to discuss vaccination with parents. MOTIVATION: Drivers were a belief in the value, safety and effectiveness of vaccination and seeing that they have an important role to play. Barriers were a tendency to blame external factors e.g. anti-vax movement and a fear of being blamed for adverse events. CONCLUSIONS: The study identified complex and inter-related barriers and drivers to health worker positive vaccination practices. These insights will now inform a process to identify and prioritize interventions.
引用
- Musa S, Skrijelj V, Kulo A, et al. Identifying barriers and drivers to vaccination: A qualitative interview study with health workers in the Federation of Bosnia and Herzegovina. Vaccine. 2020. PMID: 31980190. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2020.01.025
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。