文献速递免疫规划卫生政策与健康促进

宣传反疫苗:《疫苗揭秘》纪录片系列分析

Propagandizing anti-vaccination: Analysis of Vaccines Revealed documentary series.
PubMed 文献 · Vaccine · 2020-01-22

对九集纪录片《疫苗揭秘》进行定性分析,该片在最大的反疫苗封闭Facebook群组中被推崇为最高真相,倡导非医学儿童疫苗接种豁免,而美国儿科学会积极反对该政策。分析揭示五个主题:感知的固化科学、勾结与阴谋、煤矿中的金丝雀、恐惧诉求、个人选择的道德与必要性,并扩展认知失调、准社会互动和社会认同理论解释观众观点如何与片中专家小组一致。

要点

  • 《疫苗揭秘》在反疫苗Facebook群组中被推崇,倡导非医学儿童疫苗豁免。
  • 十四位专家小组成员包括六名偏好自然疗法的医学博士、一名疫苗伤害律师等。
  • 定性分析揭示五个主题:固化科学、勾结阴谋、煤矿金丝雀、恐惧诉求、个人选择道德。

核心结论

  • 《疫苗揭秘》通过专家证词和恐惧诉求等主题,可能使观众疫苗接种观点与片中专家小组一致。

研究设计与样本

  • 对九集纪录片系列《疫苗揭秘》进行定性分析,采用扎根理论而非先验理论假设。

主要发现

  • 定性分析揭示五个 overarching 主题:感知的固化科学、勾结与阴谋、煤矿中的金丝雀、恐惧诉求、个人选择的道德与必要性。
  • 十四位专家小组成员包括六名据称偏好自然疗法的医学博士、一名疫苗伤害律师、两名教授、一名精神科医生、Greenmedinfo.com创始人、一名全国认可的HPV疫苗临床研究专家、国家疫苗信息中心主席和三名疫苗受伤儿童父母。
  • 系列中播放了流行病学家和前CDC高级科学家的画外音片段作为政府阴谋的证据。
  • 白大衣医生的证词导致高来源可信度感知。
  • 研究者扩展了认知失调、准社会互动和社会认同理论,描述观众如何使疫苗接种观点与片中专家小组一致。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

Politically charged health propaganda films may have public health ramifications through decreased vaccination uptake, especially with expansive dissemination potential on social media. The nine-episode documentary series Vaccines Revealed, touted as foremost truth within the largest anti-vaccination closed Facebook group, advocates for non-medical childhood vaccination exemptions - a policy actively opposed by the American Academy of Pediatrics. This series is recommended specifically to parents who are on the fence about whether or not to vaccinate their children as well as new, first-time, and expectant mothers. Fourteen 'expert' panelists included: six M.D,'s who reportedly prefer natural approaches for everything from chiropractic to cardiology practice, a vaccine injury attorney, two professors, one psychiatrist, the founder of natural search engine Greenmedinfo.com, a nationally-recognized clinical research expert on the HPV vaccine, the president of the National Vaccine Information Center, and three parents of vaccine-injured children. Additionally, voiceover clips from an epidemiologist and former senior scientist at the CDC were played throughout the series as evidence of governmental conspiracy. Inclusion of these testimonies, particularly from white coat doctors, led to a perception of high source credibility. Qualitative analysis of this documentary series revealed five overarching themes: (perceived) solidified science, collusion and conspiracy, canary in the coal mine, fear appeals, and the morality and necessity of individual choice. As opposed to formulating a priori theoretical assumptions, grounded theory allowed an integrative theoretical explanation to emerge from the data. Researchers expanded cognitive dissonance, parasocial interaction, and social identification theories and described how viewers of Vaccines Revealed could come to align their views on vaccinations with those of the panelists featured in the videos.

来源:Vaccine,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Bradshaw AS, Treise D, Shelton SS, et al. Propagandizing anti-vaccination: Analysis of Vaccines Revealed documentary series. Vaccine. 2020. PMID: 31980194. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2019.12.027

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。