刚果民主共和国第十次埃博拉病毒病暴发前6个月使用的病例定义——四个邻国,2018年8月至2019年2月
CDC与刚果民主共和国、卢旺达、南苏丹和乌干达的卫生部合作,收集2018年8月至2019年2月第十次埃博拉暴发前6个月各国批准的病例定义,参照WHO标准评估四国在社区预警、疑似、可能、确诊和病例接触等类别上的一致性。各国修订次数为2至4次,病例定义复杂性随时间增加,除病例接触和确诊病例类别外,所有国家每类纳入的标准均多于WHO标准定义。病例定义一致性低且国家卫生官员对区域差异缺乏认识,可能降低跨境沟通与合作的有效性。
要点
- 各国修订埃博拉病例定义2至4次,至2019年2月均完成修订。
- 除病例接触和确诊病例类别外,各国每类标准均多于WHO标准定义。
- 四国病例定义一致性低,国家卫生官员对区域差异缺乏认识。
核心结论
- 病例定义一致性低且国家卫生官员对区域差异缺乏认识,可能降低跨境沟通与合作的有效性。
- 努力实现区域统一或考虑系统方法处理国家层面差异,可能提高跨境信息共享效率。
研究设计与样本
- CDC与刚果民主共和国、卢旺达、南苏丹和乌干达的卫生部合作,收集各国卫生部批准的埃博拉病例定义。
- 参照WHO标准病例定义,分析2018年8月至2019年2月暴发前6个月各国病例定义的变化。
- 在三个日期评估四国在社区预警、疑似、可能、确诊和病例接触等类别上的一致性。
主要发现
- 各国修订次数为2至4次,所有国家在2018年12月刚果民主共和国发病率高峰后至2019年2月均修订了埃博拉定义。
- 病例定义复杂性随时间增加,除病例接触和确诊病例类别外,所有国家每类纳入的标准均多于WHO标准定义。
- 四国病例定义一致性低,国家卫生官员对区域差异缺乏认识。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
On August 1, 2018, the Democratic Republic of the Congo (DRC) declared its 10th Ebola virus disease (Ebola) outbreak in an area with a high volume of cross-border population movement to and from neighboring countries. The World Health Organization (WHO) designated Rwanda, South Sudan, and Uganda as the highest priority countries for Ebola preparedness because of the high risk for cross-border spread from DRC (1). Countries might base their disease case definitions on global standards; however, historical context and perceived risk often affect why countries modify and adapt definitions over time, moving toward or away from regional harmonization. Discordance in case definitions among countries might reduce the effectiveness of cross-border initiatives during outbreaks with high risk for regional spread. CDC worked with the ministries of health (MOHs) in DRC, Rwanda, South Sudan, and Uganda to collect MOH-approved Ebola case definitions used during the first 6 months of the outbreak to assess concordance (i.e., commonality in category case definitions) among countries. Changes in MOH-approved Ebola case definitions were analyzed, referencing the WHO standard case definition, and concordance among the four countries for Ebola case categories (i.e., community alert, suspected, probable, confirmed, and case contact) was assessed at three dates (2). The number of country-level revisions ranged from two to four, with all countries revising Ebola definitions by February 2019 after a December 2018 peak in incidence in DRC. Case definition complexity increased over time; all countries included more criteria per category than the WHO standard definition did, except for the "case contact" and "confirmed" categories. Low case definition concordance and lack of awareness of regional differences by national-level health officials could reduce effectiveness of cross-border communication and collaboration. Working toward regional harmonization or considering systematic approaches to addressing country-level differences might increase efficiency in cross-border information sharing.
引用
- Medley AM, Mavila O, Makumbi I, et al. Case Definitions Used During the First 6 Months of the 10th Ebola Virus Disease Outbreak in the Democratic Republic of the Congo - Four Neighboring Countries, August 2018-February 2019. MMWR Morb Mortal Wkly Rep. 2020. PMID: 31917783. doi:10.15585/mmwr.mm6901a4
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。