111个国家全民健康覆盖的综合评估:一项回顾性观察研究
本研究用服务覆盖指数与灾难性卫生支出发生率的几何均值构建全民健康覆盖(UHC)指数,覆盖111个国家,数据主要来自世界银行健康公平与财务保护指标数据库(2019版)。高收入国家UHC指数总体较高,但收入组内存在差异;12个有趋势数据的国家中7个UHC指数上升,5个下降。UHC表现与政府和社会医疗保险渠道支出占比相关。
要点
- UHC指数由服务覆盖指数与灾难性支出补数的几何均值构成。
- 灾难性支出发生率低有时反映服务覆盖低,有时见于高服务覆盖国家。
- 12个有趋势数据国家中7个UHC指数上升、5个下降。
核心结论
- UHC进展可用同时反映服务覆盖与财务保护的指数来追踪。
- 人均收入是国家UHC指数得分的良好预测因素,但同一收入组或更高收入组中有些国家表现更好。
- UHC表现强与卫生预算通过政府和社会医疗保险渠道支出的占比相关。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性观察研究,覆盖111个国家。
- 服务覆盖由4项预防指标(产前保健、全程免疫、乳腺癌筛查、宫颈癌筛查)与4项治疗指标(熟练接生、住院、急性呼吸道感染治疗、腹泻治疗)的加权几何均值测量。
- 财务保护由灾难性卫生支出(超过家庭消费或收入10%)的发生率测量。
- UHC指数为服务覆盖指数与灾难性支出发生率补数的几何均值;尽可能对服务覆盖进行不平等调整,对不平等程度高的国家予以惩罚。
- 数据主要来自世界银行健康公平与财务保护指标数据库(2019版)的家庭调查数据,数据缺口用其他调查数据及必要时的非调查数据(行政、模型和填补数据)补充。
主要发现
- 灾难性支出发生率低有时反映服务覆盖低(常见于低收入国家),有时则见于服务覆盖高的情况(常见于高收入国家)。
- 在给定服务覆盖水平下,财务保护也存在差异。
- UHC指数得分在高收入国家总体较高,但收入组内存在差异。
- 对服务覆盖进行不平等调整在一些国家影响很小,但在另一些国家使UHC指数降低超过10%。
- 12个有趋势数据的国家中7个UHC指数随时间上升,平均年增幅最大为加纳1·43%、印度尼西亚1·85%、越南2·26%,多通过同时改善财务保护和服务覆盖实现;另5个国家UHC指数下降,多因财务保护恶化而服务覆盖停滞或下降。
关键数值与推荐
- 灾难性卫生支出定义为超过家庭消费或收入的10%。
- 服务覆盖指数为4项预防指标与4项治疗指标的加权几何均值。
- UHC指数为服务覆盖指数与灾难性支出发生率补数的几何均值。
- 平均年增幅:加纳1·43%、印度尼西亚1·85%、越南2·26%。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The goal of universal health coverage (UHC) requires that everyone receive needed health services, and that families who get needed services do not suffer undue financial hardship. Tracking progress towards UHC requires measurement of both these dimensions, and a way of trading them off against one another. METHODS: We measured service coverage by a weighted geometric average of four prevention indicators (antenatal care, full immunisation, and screening for breast and cervical cancers) and four treatment indicators (skilled birth attendance, inpatient admission, and treatment for acute respiratory infection and diarrhoea), financial protection by the incidence of catastrophic health expenditures (those exceeding 10% of household consumption or income), and a country's UHC performance as a geometric average of the service coverage index and the complement of the incidence of catastrophic expenditures. Where possible, we adjusted service coverage for inequality, penalising countries with a high level of inequality. The bulk of data used in this study were from the World Bank's Health Equity and Financial Protection Indicators database (2019 version), comprising data from household surveys. Gaps in the data were supplemented with other survey data and (where necessary) non-survey data from other sources (administrative, modelled, and imputed data). FINDINGS: A low incidence of catastrophic expenses sometimes reflects low service coverage (often in low-income countries) but sometimes occurs despite high service coverage (often in high-income countries). At a given level of service coverage, financial protection also varies. UHC index scores are generally higher in higher-income countries, but there are variations within income groups. Adjusting the UHC index for inequality in service coverage makes little difference in some countries, but reduces it by more than 10% in others. Seven of the 12 countries for which we were able to produce trend data have increased their UHC index over time (with the greatest average yearly increases seen in Ghana [1·43%], Indonesia [1·85%], and Vietnam [2·26%]), mostly by improving both financial protection and service coverage. Some increased their UHC index, despite reductions in financial protection, by substantially increasing their service coverage. The UHC index decreased in five of 12 countries with trend data, mostly because financial protection worsened with stagnant or declining service coverage. Our UHC indicators (except inpatient admissions) are significantly and positively associated with GDP per capita, and most are correlated with the share of health spending channelled through social health insurance and government schemes. However, associations of our UHC indicators with the share of GDP spent on health and the shares of health spending channelled through non-profit and private insurance are ambiguous. INTERPRETATION: Progress towards UHC can be tracked using an index that captures both service coverage and financial protection. Although per-capita income is a good predictor of a country's UHC index score, some countries perform better than others in the same income group or even in the income group above their own. Strong UHC performance is correlated with the share of a country's health budget that is channelled through government and social health insurance schemes. FUNDING: None.
引用
- Wagstaff A, Neelsen S. A comprehensive assessment of universal health coverage in 111 countries: a retrospective observational study. Lancet Glob Health. 2019. PMID: 31837954. doi:10.1016/S2214-109X(19)30463-2
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。